Comment by vmurthy | Hacker News Reader

Comment by vmurthy | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Not OP but here's one way:

Softbank invests in Uber India pushing up automobile demand[1]. Indian drivers buy cars manufactured by Maruti Suzuki (54% market share [2]). Maruti Suzuki is a JV between an Indian company (Maruti) and Suzuki (Japan) where-in Maruti pays 6% of sales as royalty for design and other facilities. In addition, you have to realize that Japan exports $35b of auto parts and $101b of automobiles [4]. So any lever which pushes up sales of automobiles in any nation is bound to have an impact on exports.

[1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/startups/dema...

[2] https://auto.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/passenger-veh...

[3] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/low...

[4] https://oec.world/en/profile/country/jpn/

+1 Indeed, one of the reasons for the current auto-slowdown in India appears to be the drastic decrease in benefits offered by Taxi aggregators, which is hitting taxi drivers hard. Can't complain, since taxis saturate the roads in Bengaluru already.

> taxis saturate the roads in Bangalore already

In Indiranagar (a popular, hip neighbourhood in Bangalore), you might have to wait for an hour to get an Uber or Ola, on weekday mornings too! Hence a lot of people are using Yulu (India's Bird).

Add HSR Layout to that list , too. I’ve started using a combination of Bounce( two wheeler point-to-point rental ) for <2km travel , public transport for longer distance travel and cabs as the last option.

Okay, now where does all the demand for these Indian taxi services come from that are actually going to pay for all of these automobile imports? It's not like Uber demand is insatiable. The notion that investing in Uber is going to drive the auto industry (which is completely contrary to the mission of these transportation companies) is an odd one.

I can see that, at the margins, a company can spend money where it thinks it it can receive complimentary benefits. But this idea that you can spend your way into riches is a fallacy.

So, I think we agree on some things, mainly that Japan is printing money and Softbank is a beneficiary and is using that cash to spread around the tech industry. Cheap money. Except I think it will backfire, eventually.

Exactly.

lol

Reply on news.ycombinator.com