IMHO: Because Github just came at the right time for a free "no strings attached" project hosting solution when Sourceforge decided to become evil. That was the reason why I switched to Github anyway.
That Github used this strange version control system cobbled together by the Linux kernel devs for their specific workflow was a bit weird, but that wasn't a showstopper for moving to Github.
After all it was just one amongst many version control systems, and a VCS shouldn't be the centre of the universe anyway, over time Github would probably offer different systems anyway after they become more popular.
Nobody expected that Github was essentially a Trojan horse ;)