But the ban also prevents that particular customer from receiving bad service. Some things are not meant to be.
Since the customer needs to use that lot, they would probably stop using ZipCar at that point—but that's better than being banned forever if their life situation changes.
> which any engineer worth their salt should’ve predicted - this is not rocket science
There are probably tons of other issues you don't know about. Making it work offline would probably increase the attack surface, &c.
Because companies routinely do the former.
50% is GP's after-the-fact description of how often the car failed to start. It's not an actual failure rate that GP knew about before they parked.
What's the appropriate number of towings for one customer due to that customer's intentional actions before you kick them off the service?
Now that I think about it, I believe unlocking does work regardless of cell service (as long as you don't extend the reservation, and try to unlock it after the original reservation time ends).
I had the car towed twice:
1) First time, the car wouldn't start because the battery was dead while parked underground with no cell service.
2) Second time, the reservation was about to expire while parked without cell service, and I extended it on the app, but the car couldn't know that since the cellular unit couldn't phone home.
EDIT: For what it's worth, I don't blame Zipcar for banning an unprofitable customer. I acknowledge that i was definitely pushing my luck by parking there a 2nd time after the first incident.
After a while of this, they banned me from the restaurant for ordering the tuna salad.”
In that case, yeah, they should ban "you".
I say they have tuna salad on the menu, but they apparently can't always serve it to everyone.
Your suggestion that he order something else to eat is like telling a ZipCar customer to move to a different condominium or whatever.
They don't "have" to do anything, provided they aren't discriminating against him on the basis of a prohibited factor like race or gender. Just as a restaurant doesn't have to serve you (subject to the same caveat).
But the important thing here to note is that the hypothetical restaurant has organized their business in such a way that some customers cannot get what they claim to serve, just as ZipCar has organized their business such that some customers cannot enjoy the service they claim to offer.
They don't have to do anything, but I object to blaming the customer for their choice to run their business in such a way that a very ordinary thing that some customers can do, others cannot.
based on the story above I agree, knowingly (and after a few occurrences you should understand there's a problem) damaging the service should lead to a ban or at least a warning.
It appears they're aware of the problem, but certain known issues prevent access (cellular unit draining car battery seems to be the common one and sounds like something that should be fixable).
AFAIK they did not say you shouldn't park underground nor did they explain their various failure modes and how to avoid them.