Therefore any successful litigation against him would require reference to some law that makes it unlawful to disseminate the actual information. It's difficult to imagine how such a law would hold up to a rigorous first amendment challenge.
Your other posts make it clear that you believe this guy has breached some private contractual obligation to Sony, and I'm curious to know where you're getting that idea.
2. Kindly avoid the condescending tone.
2. Right on here, actually. Last night I was particularly annoyed at dangrossman's tone elsewhere (eg "So you've never heard of an NDA?") hence the snark in my original post, but after sleeping on it I'm sort of embarrassed it got to me that way.
This prof will likely not get in trouble, however my comment was regarding the general sentiment - the claim that you cannot get in trouble for helping to violate someone else's contract is dangerously incorrect. The bar might be high, I don't know enough about that, but in general you most certainly can get in trouble that way.
I was thinking about the case where Kai-Fu Lee breached his contract with Microsoft by joining Google, and Google ended up sued and paying a settlement for the instigation.
Via the DMCA, the U.S. government prohibits "dissemination" of "technology, devices, or services" designed to circumvent copy-protection systems. The first-amendment generally doesn't allow the government to prohibit "dissemination" of things that qualify as "speech", so the open question is whether any of the things being prohibited qualify.
(Universal v. Reimerdes, one of the DeCSS cases, upheld the DMCA against a similar challenge, so it's an uphill battle. A stronger case would probably be an attempt to suppress a cryptography-research paper via the DMCA, since publishing papers is the kind of activity usually assumed to be protected by the First Amendment. There've been a few potential test cases of that sort, but the plaintiffs seem to always back down before they get to a ruling.)
You can contract away your right to speech as easily as anything else. This has nothing to do with the first amendment.
Oh, that's right, they'll get the government to step in.
With regards to your second issue, you're making the classic mistake of conflating a user's right to free speech with a provider's obligation to distribute that speech. Facebook has no obligation to distribute anything, and choosing not to distribute some things is not a limitation on free speech.
Only by suing you, civilly, in a civilian court of law. Unless the company is the United States Military, you can't really be thrown in jail for breaking the contract on its own. One would have to willfully spread the information learned while under the NDA, with the intent of that information causing damage, like a security hole in some bank's network a hired pen-tester finds that allows an attacker to illegally obtain money.
The only time a court upholds the first amendment is when striking down a law made by congress, a state or a local government as unconstitutional. Read the bill of rights. They are limitations on the power of government.
Well, technically correct of course, it doesn't have to be signed. But it's an open question where the lines are drawn with regard to agreeing to a contract you never read and understood.
http://www.businessinsider.com/dead-womans-name-robo-signing...