I like to give to charities, but I've built up a couple of rules:
- I won't give you a credit card number, because I've seen too many dark patterns about canceling recurring donations. It stinks for online giving because Paypal is awful, but it's basically the only way I can guarantee that I won't need to make phone calls if my giving habits change.
- You always get a unique email address that I can cancel or sort, no matter who you are. Fastmail thankfully makes this very easy.
- Unless I really trust you not to mail me, I won't give you my real address.
Patreon, for all of its problems, has the right idea here. Donors control their subscriptions, and their addresses/emails aren't shared by default. I'd love a similar service for more conventional giving.