I'm sure they all gave up because of politics, too, and not because systemd gets way more right than it gets wrong despite a vocal minority of noncontributory angst.
Unfortunately, it will probably take ten years to see the real effects of these decisions on the ecosystem. I hope you're right that this is the way to go, but I fear I'll be right that Linux will be at least as opaque as Windows to anyone who wants an entry point into learning about operating systems and systems administration without having to pay to take classes.
I much prefer my system with systemd, because it's less opaque than when i started using Linux in 1998 (attempted earlier, but failed).