As Bloomberg reported: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-04/the-big-h...
Apple: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/10/what-businessweek-got...
Amazon: https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/security/setting-the-record-str...
Supermicro: https://www.supermicro.com/en/pressreleases/supermicro-refut...
I would need a legal opinion to understand if their denials would put them at legal risk were the article to be true (in which case I would be much more inclined to believe their denials) and whether their denials tell us anything about potential government gag orders (if the article is correct about a top-secret investigation, I would imagine they would have legal obligations around what they can say).
I don't want to use false equivalence to make it seem like I believe this article is as likely to be true as not (I think it's unlikely or at least extremely misleading), but everything I can see from my not-so-informed position is consistent with both a true and a false article.
Why should anyone believe it true without some kind of proof.
The story is essentially that there was a breakthrough in an effort that everyone in the world is pursuing (hardware supply chain attacks) and then everyone involved behaved as you'd expect them to behave (secretive at first and then defensively once the secret was out). While I don't expect people to believe it, I do expect some evidence if you're going to call it bullshit.
The more fantastic the story, the greater the burden of proof needed to sustain it. It’s never been the public’s burden to disprove a story that no one has ever heard before. And at this point, enough time has passed since the story broke without any evidence being put forth that it’s reasonable for people to think that yes, in fact, the story is likely bullshit.
When we are talking about national security, the consequences of sources being identified are so high that it is not surprising that Bloomberg is unwilling to provide primary sources.
I don't think anyone is actually saying that everything Bloomberg publishes is suspect without exception (the quote above notwithstanding). Nobody would question, based on previous history, a Bloomberg story claiming water is still wet.
Where they do lack credibility now are stories claiming bombshells relating to technology companies.
In this instance we have both Alex Stamos, who knows a lot of inside information and is a well-regarded security expert, and the head of WhatsApp itself both denying the claims. And any time a company or one of its high level representatives makes a material statement of fact, investors are going to pay close attention. If they prove to be wrong, an army of shareholders' attorneys are going to march to court to extract a pound of flesh. If there were even a shred of possibility that these stories were true, these folks -- as well as the leaders at Amazon and Apple implicated in the earlier stories -- would clam up instead of going on the record unambiguously denying the stories.
This is an article about an attack so advanced it's generally considered impossible, using the most valuable attack vector in the most important battlefield (see DNI Maguire's hearing answer to the biggest threat facing America) between the world's two superpowers. Would it really be that shocking if, after an initial leak, the US government was able to shut down leaks?
You make good points, particularly around the public denials, and I don't want to debate this any further (I was mostly railing against that ridiculous quote), but I think people are being pretty quick to claim this report is false rather than probably false.
130,000 people worked on the atomic bomb for 6 years in secret - when it comes to matters the government considers crucial to national security (and cutting edge breakthroughs in cyber warfare would certainly qualify), silence can be kept.
Bloomberg has provided no evidence at all that it is true.
A report that is not supported by any evidence is not just ‘unconfirmed’. It is bullshit plain and simple.
Sometimes reporters can work that transparently, but they can also report stories based on private information, and your only choice is whether to trust that they're telling the truth.
For example, a newspaper will sometimes report things based on anonymous sources. You don't get to know who the sources are. You just have to trust that the newspaper isn't making things up and properly vetted their sources.
Of course, that doesn't mean you immediately start trusting any random reporter or newspaper, but trust is based on track record and reputation, not being transparent about sources in every story.
If this story is real and sources are made public, people are almost certainly going to jail - some of those sources (if real) had to have security clearances.
Can't replicate or check info? Then there's no information to speak about in the first place.