All the evidence is out there in Hackage. I backed up my points with some argumentation at least, and you dismissed it based on personal experience that we have no way of verifying. So, not changing my mind yet.
You've recounted your experience and detailed that you have seen issues with things in Hackage, and I won't claim your experience is invalid. I just won't let you claim your experience is that much more valid than someone else's without proof.