Hacker News Reader

From the article it seems like a reasonable take-down, a developer made a cash-grab app to capitalize on the controversy, which is against policy.

If the app was made as a political statement, it wouldn't have in-app purchases IMO.

View on HN

Why shouldn't a political app be allowed to make purchases? Why does that make the app's political position any less legitimate?

Political protesters being paid is generally seen as a bad thing. It cheapens the message, especially when instead of a donation link you use tactics typically used by massive corporations targeting the weak-willed and children to do it. I'm not gonna get up in arms for it but they are clearly trying to profit from the controversy. The political position isn't illegitimate, the developer's motives are.

The app developer supposedly made $150 before the app was taken down. Hardly a successful cash grab. If people didn’t feel the app provide value worth the cost of its services, they can choose not to buy. What is Google’s place in the making of that decision?

There is no reason to give Google the benefit of the doubt here. They’ve been making efforts to re-enter The China Market (tm) for years.

[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/apple-pulls-hong-kong-cop-track...?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com