That seems obvious in general, but should be extra obvious to anyone who has ever received a bill from anything in the US health system.
That seems obvious in general, but should be extra obvious to anyone who has ever received a bill from anything in the US health system.
It's The Prices, Stupid (2003): https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/full/10.1377/hlthaff.22.3....
It's Still The Prices, Stupid (2019): https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2018.05144
It is similar to the health care systems. The US system is awesome at doing really crazy life saving stuff. For example US is probably the best in keeping premature babies alive. In addition it has a ton of resources. If you want an MRI scan, you can get one in the US pretty quickly and easily. Also, the profits in the US subsidize worldwide drug development. This is why, if you look where all the really rich rulers decide to go for surgery or other complicated care, it is the US.
Canada and other countries optimize for the median case and rely on the US for their outliers. Look at the instances of Canadians coming to the US for surgery or MRI scans because they cannot get them in Canada in a timely manner.
[0]: https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/infant-...
The one study I could find from 2000 that compares them showed
>Relative risks for infant death from all causes among singletons born at 32 through 33 gestational weeks were 6.6 (95% confidence interval [CI], 6.1-7.0) in the United States in 1995 and 15.2 (95% CI, 13.2-17.5) in Canada in 1992-1994;
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&as_vis...
The fact that the births of premature children in this category is lower in Canada could, perhaps, point to the opposite conclusion: because health care in Canada is less driven by profit, we are seeing better care before birth which could be lowering this number.
"Our results were fairly consistent between the United States and Canada. The RRs of mortality associated with mild and moderate preterm birth were generally higher in Canada. A small part of these differences in gestational age–specific mortality was explained by the lower absolute and relative mortality risks among US black vs white preterm infants, but the RRs for Canada remained substantially higher than those for the United States even after restricting the US analysis to non-Hispanic whites (ie, 8.1 vs 15.2 at 32-33 gestational weeks and 3.3 vs 4.5 at 34-36 gestational weeks for total infant mortality among all singleton live births). An even smaller part of the difference was the result of the slightly lower absolute risks for term (birth at ≥37 gestational weeks) births in Canada (ie, total infant mortality of 3.0 vs 3.1 per 1000 live births for Canada in 1992-1994 vs the United States in 1995). We are currently investigating other potential explanations and particularly whether the differences might be artifacts caused by errors in estimation of gestational age. Regardless of the explanation, however, the prevalence of births in these gestational age categories was much lower in Canada than in the United States, and the EFs were therefore similar in the 2 countries."
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/19299...
If that were true, why would a US Senator go to Canada for surgery then?
https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/politics/2019/01/...
(Though the hospital also gets some $ from the government, so I'm not quite sure what it means to be "private"...)
I think you can have both claims to be true: the vast majority of complicated procedures are best-in-class in the US, but there are some centers of excellence elsewhere as well.
Prices are high in healthcare in part due to inelastic demand, but much moreso due to supply constriction. For just one, particularly egregious example of this:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_need
If you want to open a new hospital in many states in the US, you need to acquire this "Certificate of Need". Who approves this certificate? Other hospitals in the area. It's as though Google required the permission of Yahoo to form a new search engine.
That is, of course, after my 'gas insurer' comped the station anywhere between $0 and $25, that number being determined by the astrological position, and retrograde state of the planets.
I entirely agree that hospitals are part of the problem, but I think that casting this as a supply and demand issue is oversimplifying the issue. People who need health care very often cannot choose to "shop around" for their provider, the increase in mergers make it less likely there are any competitors in their area. Agreements between hospitals and insurance companies often place other health care providers "outside network", thus artificially increasing their costs. In the same way consumers do not choose their hospital, they also frequently cannot choose their insurance provider; often the health insurance comes along with their employment.
In my opinion, the tangled co-dependency between hospitals, insurance companies, pharmaceutical companies and all of the lesser industries that depend on them are all factors in the rising costs. Every step of the way along the chain, profit is maximized at the expense of the patient. We will need large scale change in order to address the issue and I don't think it will be easy.
I hope that some kind of "medicare for all" system will start moving things in the right direction. In my opinion, this system is failing everyone except the very wealthy.
[0]: https://www.pwc.com/us/en/industries/health-industries/libra...
You're citing this as a case against supply restriction...but I think it makes the opposite point. Hospitals are consolidating because it increases their pricing power. However, that only works because it's so hard to create new hospitals. If it were easier for new entrants to enter the market, consolidation amongst existing providers wouldn't have the power that it seems to.
> I entirely agree that hospitals are part of the problem, but I think that casting this as a supply and demand issue is oversimplifying the issue. People who need health care very often cannot choose to "shop around" for their provider, the increase in mergers make it less likely there are any competitors in their area. Agreements between hospitals and insurance companies often place other health care providers "outside network", thus artificially increasing their costs. In the same way consumers do not choose their hospital, they also frequently cannot choose their insurance provider; often the health insurance comes along with their employment.
Ya, this is certainly a problem as well. I suppose I would consider it to be within the umbrella of "supply and demand" though.