I've run nothing but Windows Defender on my own machines, and haven't had any issue since before Windows XP.
On the other hand, I've had to use a whole host of shit under duress at work, and all I've ever seen it do is slow beefy desktops to a crawl, delete parts of various dev tools, and fight over who can lock and scan files. Now they are tied into sketchy cloud services that require creating logins, and are getting themselves hacked.