Yes. Originally it was a thought experiment. Just like mathematicians can imagine an idea and use a notation without creating a compiler.
McCarthy early on proposed to write a compiler - actually this was one of the very very early papers:
J. McCarthy. Memo to P. M. Morse: A Proposal for a compiler. Memo CC-56, Computation Center, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, December 13, 1957, 19 pages.
http://www.softwarepreservation.org/projects/LISP/MIT/CC-56....