I do wonder who is making up these rules and why do they care what I say about Google? If I talk frequently about the same Yahoo story one that is neutral and I am neutral are you going to tell me to stop/say that is spam too?
Repetition spoils curiosity. When users repeat the same thing so often that it starts to sound like an idée fixe, other users get upset and call it spamming, and eventually we have to ask the person to just avoid that topic. Google isn't the issue; there's plenty of criticism of Google on HN, as of every other big tech co.
Since our last exchange I haven't posted anything about it or had planned to. Here in this hidden thread I saw another member pondered something I did after our last exchange. I fully didnt understand why anyone would care that much about what I have to say about Google or why I loathe Google to the point of being told no more.
Overall I still dont fully understand it, but will refrain from talking negatively about Google (unless extremely relevant or not say why) as it leads me to point to a reason that is upsetting to various HN members(whoever they may be).
If you want people to listen, you have to make it entertaining. If you want to tell a story, then tell a story! Spend a few hours putting all of your thoughts down on paper (not in a comment, but probably not on real paper, ha; put it on your own website). Go into juicy detail with your experiences. Make people feel like they were in your shoes. Put them in your mindset, your hopes and dreams, make them identify with your motivations. Make them feel how exciting it was when you were invited to Google, and how disappointing it felt to realize what it was really about. Don't tell them; show them. When you do this well, you get people on your side.
Everyone has a story to tell. But if you want people to listen, you have to really work for your audience and show them that you're doing it for them.
Turn it into something fun! I dug deeply into your comment history out of curiosity. The reason everyone is telling you to keep quiet is that when you write, you sound angry and hurt. But we have all experienced situations where someone has made us angry or hurt us. That's what power is: the ability to hurt you and not worry about consequences. It happens.
For various reasons, it's in my best interest to say nothing here. But I note you've been with HN since 2007, and have contributed 594 comments. That counts for something.
So, word of advice: when you come to an entertainment site, you have to be entertaining. But your HN profile, which is supposed to be about you, is about Google. You call them pigs, right there in your profile. Even if that were hypothetically true, what are people supposed to think when they read that? I search your comment history and see that 85 of your 594 comments are about Google: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
That's a ratio of 14.3%. Almost 15% of your sum total output on HN has been about Google, since 2007. In comparison, the #1 HN user by karma has mentioned Google 1,561 times out of 53,789 comments = 2.9% of the time. You're talking about google almost 5 times more frequently than other long-time members. That's why people are saying it's an obsession.
When people wrong you, and then you make your life about them, that's just them controlling you. Why let them win like that?
Now, the reason I said all of this, and why I'm sticking my neck out here to post this comment, is that I suspect -- just a hunch -- that you might have otherwise been inclined to bring up Google in the future. But I also suspect that if you keep doing this, and you don't change your methods, you're going to lose your HN privileges, and that no one will disagree with that decision. Poof. Gone.
It's Friday, man. It's the weekend. You in Chicago? If so, let me know! We can go out to a bar and I promise I'll really listen to everything you have to say about Google and about HN.
Just... have fun with life, you know? There's more to life than all of this. You're an inventor! Don't you still find joy in finding things to make? What happened to that creative spark?
I believe in you, and I believe you can still invent things and make positive contributions to the world. Don't let all this get you down. Just remember: HN is supposed to be fun. That's the real strength of the community.
Best of luck!
I was shocked to hear and be told I can no longer talk negatively about Google on Hacker News and provide my reason why if asked.
Because it's baiting people into allowing you to grind your axe? I just looked up what you are referring to, and while like the mods I agree there's likely something to your story, that doesn't mean it needs to be injected into every conversation, nor that you can be excused for saying "they are pigs" with regard to Google.
The job of the mods is to provide a civil place for discourse that people enjoy and find benefit in participating in. If they think you repeatedly bringing up something that you've already expressed on multiple occasions is impeding those goals, it's their job to take action.
The fact that you've started the same behavior over their actions to correct your prior behavior (note how the person you replied to thought you accidentally replied to the wrong person?) is evidence that you didn't understand what they tried to express initially, or possibly don't care.
The solution to this is simple, stay on topic, or at least make sure your tangents have a reason. A discussion about Google wrongdoing, or poor experiences, or even weird interview problems would be a good place to bring out your Google grievances. A discussion about who the moderators are and how they come to consensus for purely educational reasons is not an entirely appropriate forum to air your grievances about past moderator decisions, as it's a large shift in tone, and that's ignoring its tendency to derail any conversation it happens in.
If your message has merit, it will be better received when it's in the right context. In the wrong context, it's likely to be ignored, and possibly even negatively received, as you've seen.