Hacker News Reader

Comment by cft | Hacker News Reader

That's not an issue at all, for large transactions. The real issue is each payment being a taxable event, due to IRS treating it as property, rather than currency. You literally have to report each payment on schedule D and calculate its cost basis! This burden kills any legal US adoption.

View on HN

I thought the Bitcoin community were publicly stating that Bitcoin is optimised as a "Store of value" rather than a currency to be used for transactions? Which is it?

It's properties are more in line with a store of value, especially the deflationary aspect, but the line between a store of value and a currency is blurry. Gold also has more properties of a store of value than a currency, and it's used more as a store of value globally, yet some parts of North Africa and the Middle East are using the gold dinar as a currency. It can be both.

not in a modern tax regime, not really. If it's a store of value, like say bonds, then it's property.

You have to report gold transactions, too, after all.

If you wanted to know how it's taxed, you could've asked that directly. I didn't see anything in your question about how it was taxed. Short answer specific to the US (IANAL): capital gains on every transaction, counting transactions between different cryptocurrencies as if you'd sold your original currency for USD and then bought the other cryptocurrency using USD. These are just arbitrary laws though, they have nothing to do with the actual properties of a given cryptocurrency.

the comment I was replying to was specifically about tax (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21443141)

According to the Austrian School of economics, a thing has to be valuable or seen as a store of value before it can be used as a medium of exchange. This podcast has a great explanation of this: https://stephanlivera.com/episode/76/.

Why would you spend bitcoin if you didn't have to if you believed it’s going to be a lot more valuable 5 or 10 years from now?

Famously, a guy spent 10,000 BTC to buy two pizzas during the early days; that’s over $94 million USD at today's prices.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com