A quick search shows B.A.T.M.A.N. (http://www.open-mesh.org/), but it looks a little tricky to setup. Are there any simple ways for non-technical users to run a mesh network node? A "click to install and run" solution would be ideal, but I'd be interested in hearing about other people's experiences with mesh networks.
I haven't set one up myself but if the government did kill the internet I'd take it as a good time to start creating a city-by-city mesh, hopefully hooking up with other people with the same idea. If the government leaves the regular lines off for too long, it may actually end up being a good thing. I don't think the kill-switch strategy would work so well in the US, so long as it's not short-term, but it's possible the people who want the ability of a kill-switch haven't thought it through.
There is also this:
And a bunch of others.
It's not targeted at laptops, but at embedded boards somewhat like you would find in a commodity Linksys home router.
The best help they can get is, IMO, coders and new hardware to develop for/test on.
http://stevencrowley.com/2010/09/02/ultra-wideband-how-regul...
There are many devices using UWB, but as far as I know, none of them allow long-range communication:
- UWB failed because it was out-competed
- it was out-competed because it was using a new spectrum, while the competition was using the already existing 2.4GHz channel, so it had to deal with the FCC when the competition simply didn't.
i.e. it sounds like they just had an extra hurdle to jump (and a bureaucratic one at that) that made it hard to win, rather than the FCC actively attempting to prevent it's use.
It's depressing, but I think it's important for us to be realistic about how bad the situation really is if we're ever going to do something serious about fixing it. The reason we still have most of the privileges we do isn't because we're too powerful to have them taken away from us, it's because there hasn't yet been a need to take them away, or because we haven't (yet) elected someone with that sort of style (we certainly HAVE been too close for comfort).
I mean, America is effectively bankrolling the Egyptian censorship. There clearly aren't any qualms with the tactics.
Do you really think the same corporations that extensively lobby the government now are going to sit idly by while the government shuts this Internet thing down?
They're going to say: "how much will you pay us to help you do it?" The answer will be "a lot" as it's always been. And the answer if they don't comply will be "you're finished". Standard mafioso tactics. Are you really expecting giant corporations to have principles at all, not to mention principles they are willing to sacrifice themselves for? Anyone within who suggests they should will hastily be shown the door. That's how the modern corporation is structured. The filthily rich throughout history haven't exactly been the harbingers of revolution.
The regulations that hobble the pharmaceutical industry today (you can debate about whether they're good or not; this isn't the point) were initially sought by the industry, in order to weed out snake oil charlatans. A significant early backer of gun control regulation was the Ruger corporation, because the regulations were structured in a way that affected imports (like Beretta) much more severely.
Actually, more than one revolution was an attempt by the rich to overthrow the powerful.
It's not really the point though. Perhaps I'm wrong about the importance of the wealthy in revolutions throughout history. The point is it's naive to expect giant corporations to take enormous risks in defying government power. Wealthy individuals? Perhaps. Perhaps small businesses or startups. But not big corporations--they are too profit-centered and conservative and they have too much to lose. Just look at Vodafone's complicit behavior in Egypt. It's a direct parallel.
Most of the founding fathers of the United States were rich, you know.
All it takes for the vast majority of the internet to become unusable for the larger fraction of the population is to take the .com, .net and .org TLDs down. Your packets will still route but where do you want them to go? It would take long enough for people to regroup and find work-arounds that more permanent ways of blocking access could be rolled out.
Definitely untrue. How familiar are you with how the Internet works? Google and other major websites are massively multihomed: they peer with tens or hundreds or perhaps thousands of other ISPs and backbones in as many different peering points around the world.
> All it takes for the vast majority of the internet to become unusable for the larger fraction of the population is to take the .com, .net and .org TLDs down.
8.8.8.8 is an easy enough number to memorize. So is 8.8.4.4. How long do you think it would DNS admins there or anywhere else to fix their servers not to flush their caches? Certainly less time than it would take the US government to shut down thousands of redundant peering points.
Familiar enough with it to have written a TCP/IP stack. You?
> Google and other major websites are massively multihomed: they peer with tens or hundreds or perhaps thousands of other ISPs and backbones in as many different peering points around the world.
Yes, that was the point, the hosts are still up but you can't reach them. Kill port 53 and the net might as well be dead for 99.9% of all hosts. Most links in google point to other websites, not to google.
> 8.8.8.8 is an easy enough number to memorize. So is 8.8.4.4.
Yep, those would be first to go. Technically those are under the control of the US military anyway, they're on US soil and within 100 miles of an army base. Or did you think there would be a stand-off between a bunch of nerds and a bunch of military long enough to make a difference?
Take out a few key peering locations and the net is dark.
In North America I would say Mae-East, Mae-West and Front 151 in Toronto and that would be 70% of the work done, you can mop up after that.
> How long do you think it would DNS admins there or anywhere else to fix their servers not to flush their caches?
Ironically restarting bind with a new config clears the cache. I'm sure you could find a work-around for that but it might actually be an advantage to start thinking about this ahead of time and making sure that you can survive in 'island' mode without access to DNS.
Those DHS seizures targeted the domans for a good reason, people do not access the net through IP addresses conceptually, they use the DNS, the rest of the magic gets hidden under the hood. The HN crowd may be at an advantage in such a situation (it's just another challenge) but I think for the majority of the folks out there it would be curtains.
> Certainly less time than it would take the US government to shut down thousands of redundant peering points.
I think you're vastly underestimating the capabilities of the US army. There are active reserves in/around every major city, it wouldn't take more than a few hours. Extremely well organized guys with guns are a pretty effective means of shutting down technology.
How many sys admins do you know that will take a bullet to keep their router up after being commanded to shut it down?
That doesn't mean that I didn't wish you were right, but we can safely assume that if a government that (still) had control of its military decided that its citizens should not longer have internet access that they will not within a few hours of that decision being made.
I work directly with it on one of the world's busiest destination ASes on a daily basis.
> Yep, those would be first to go. Technically those are under the control of the US military anyway, they're on US soil and within 100 miles of an army base.
I'm not quite sure what to do with such a glaringly incorrect statement. 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 are anycast-routed ips with multiple servers in places across the globe. Here's a list of the servers that host those ips:
64.233.162.0/24 gru
64.233.168.0/24 iad
66.102.12.0/24 grq
72.14.202.0/24 tpe
72.14.212.0/24 dls
74.125.112.0/24 chs
74.125.114.0/24 chs
74.125.126.0/24 dls
74.125.152.0/24 tpe
74.125.154.0/24 dls
74.125.156.0/24 atl
74.125.158.0/24 atl
74.125.38.0/24 fra
74.125.42.0/24 ber
74.125.44.0/24 atl
74.125.46.0/24 atl
74.125.52.0/24 dls
74.125.64.0/24 atl
74.125.66.0/24 atl
74.125.76.0/24 grq
74.125.78.0/24 grq
74.125.86.0/24 bud
74.125.90.0/24 mrn
74.125.92.0/24 mrn
74.125.94.0/24 cbf
208.117.247.0/24 pao
209.85.142.0/24 dub
209.85.174.0/24 kul
209.85.224.0/24 cbf
209.85.226.0/24 bru
209.85.228.0/24 bru
How many of those do you think the US government can shutdown? It would have to find some way to blackhole Google's AS entirely to do so. Do you think that's within its capabilities?
> I think you're vastly underestimating the capabilities of the US army...How many sys admins do you know that will take a bullet to keep their router up after being commanded to shut it down?
I think you're vastly underestimating the autonomy of individual soldiers in the Army. I know a lot of soldiers--my wife's an active duty O-3--and I don't know a single one who would actually shoot a person for refusing to shut down a router, especially in the context of an attempted government shutdown of the Internet.
> I don't know a single one who would actually shoot a person for refusing to shut down a router, especially in the context of an attempted government shutdown of the Internet.
That's called desertion.
Would they also refuse to take foreigners hostage and place them in confinement outside of US soil to stop them from having access to the courts?
Typically when people with guns show up the options are 'do this or else', where or else can be anything from we'll take you prisoner to we'll put holes in you where they do not belong. And you will end up doing what you're told.
Really this is an insane discussion, no ISP would hold out for more than 15 minutes to the moment of shutdown, you can choose it to be an orderly one with a chance of getting stuff back up once the order is lifted to one where stuff will be shut down by major force. Shutdown the power (and the generators) and it's curtains anyway.
I understand that you'd like it to be otherwise. Let's hope we'll never find out who was right ;)
The government there strategically left the one provider up that they themselves use and all others are down.
I'd imagine that if a relatively low-tech country like Egypt can pull off a sophisticated partitioning like that on a moments notice that most other countries would be able to do so as well but probably in a more precise manner.
> A parasite can't risk outright killing its host.
Beware of people with nothing to lose.
On another note, during WWII the mere possession of a radio was grounds for execution in plenty of places, let alone a transmitter, but that didn't stop people from having radios concealed in the most ingenious ways.
So that's why the radios were so important, and that's why they were illegal.