Because the resources it'd take to kill the internet manually matter
They only need to turn off one big ISP or 2 before the others are going to shut down themselves. Look at what happened with Wikileaks.
If someone can always find a flaw in crypto implementations,
why bother with cryptography?
That's a pretty big IF, because it depends on finding flaws, and there is no recipe for that and you're also not certain if you're going to find any, regardless of the time/resources invested.
Also, crypto algorithms are public, peer reviewed and usually you're going to find out if a flaw exists sooner or later. And because there isn't any available method to make brute force attacks any easier or feasible if the key is large.
I am pretty sure the government can shut down the Internet, but I can bet they aren't able to decrypt my communications if I won't allow it ;-)