But...
Some forget that calories_in is the output of a function with multiple input variables, and calories_burned is also the output of a function with multiple input variables, plus whatever your wrist-worn fitness monitor says you burned directly through exercise.
If you stand in the freezing cold for 15 minutes, and then go back inside, and you still have some brown fat left after infancy, it will add to calories_burned for a little while. If you are insulin resistant, and you cut carbs out of your diet for a while, that will tend to deduct from calories_in, because the foods you are now eating impact your competing appetite and satiety functions differently, such that satiety is winning more often now. If you exercise vigorously, your calories_burned rises by when you burned directly, but you will also increase metabolism for a few hours afterward, and the fitness monitor won't tell you that, but it will also boost your appetite function, and your food scale might catch that.
If you eat a lot of veggies, wheat, or whole grains, you get a lot of fiber.
What we really care about is why people are eating more than they expend, and how we can get people to lose weight and maintain a healthy weight unconsciously.
For example, diet soda has no calories, but has biochemical interactions that mimic those of regular soda, resulting in the trigger of hormones like insulin that trigger the body to store fat. Even worse, other biochemical reactions can kill the good gut flora lower down in your digestive system. Based on some studies, you're arguably better off just drinking regular soda despite the calories.
As well as when and what foods you eat may change your metabolism.
In other words, "calories in" and "calories burned".
evidence?
Well 2% is a HUGE difference. That means if two people eat exactly the same diet and same level of activity, assuming a 2000 calorie daily intake, the person with a 2% slower metabolism is going to be 40 lbs heavier over a 10 year period.
There is nothing even slightly controversial in that statement.
umm what...
That is the only way to lose lean body mass. You should be thinking "its not clear that removing carbs is reason you're losing weight." Your bayesian priors are completely backwards.
The reality is that protein and fat are more satiating so people eat less and lose weight when they cut out carbs.
In reality it’s more nuanced:
“It is true that fat has more calories than carbohydrates, including sugar. But by that logic, a sugary beverage is better for you than a handful of nuts. That’s just not what the unbiased studies have shown. Looking only at calories ignores the metabolic effects of each calorie; the source of the calorie changes how you digest it and how you retrieve energy from it.”
From https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/theres-no-sugar-coating-...
But I disagree that the quote you presented somehow claims that a person can lose weight while not being in a deficit. It's physically impossible. That doesn't mean other processes aren't going on, or that you shouldn't consider other things like macronutrients and micronutrients when trying to construct a "healthy" diet.
For example, insufficient protein (or protein precursors like amino acids) can cause the breakdown of muscle, which is denser and weighs more than fat. You'd have to have a sizable excess of calories to have the fat storage to cancel out the loss of muscle mass.
Feel free to post some pubmed studies if you like.
Not true. It's possible to lose different types of weight (i.e., muscle or bone) due to the body's inability to repair such tissue in the absence of proper diet sources. For example, if you drink 2000 calories/day as your only food source, you will lose bone mass and muscle mass over time, and the fat stored by your body (if any) will weigh less than the bone or muscle mass lost.
There's no magic from eating fat/protein/carbs.
Fat, carbs, and protein all have different roles in the body. Luckily, our diets generally get enough of all 3 that it's not that much of an issue...but lots of research shows that having the optimal balance of FPC for your current body condition and activity results can drastically affect performance, sleep, behavior, etc.
Literally every diet has been shown to cause weight loss if paired with a caloric deficit...
Low carb. Low fat. Low protein. No fruits. Only fruits. Etc.
If calorie in/calorie out worked then obesity wouldn't be a problem in the USA because 99% of obese people have been treated that way.
The types of fat and carbs in your diet matter. You can eat healthy carbs all day (i.e., vegetables) and not gain weight over a year, or eat unhealthy fats (i.e., trans fats) and gain 10 pounds in a week.
> If calorie in/calorie out worked then obesity wouldn't be a problem in the USA because 99% of obese people have been treated that way.
There are two ways of looking at whether a diet "works." First, what happens when a person actually follows the diet. This is what most people are curious about. Second, what happens when you tell a person to follow the diet. This is what all the scientific papers are written about because it's what doctors, public health experts, and other researchers care about. Don't get the two mixed up. From the first point of view, there's a wide variety of very different diets that "work." From the second point of view, basically nothing works, and there is a never-ending (re)search in which occasionally somebody announces weak evidence that the diet du jour is better than yesterday's favored diet, but there's no reason to believe the current conventional wisdom will last any longer than previous expert consensuses such as the need to eat low-fat.
Sticking to diets is really really hard.
And as stated in comments below, the hormonal differences are also claimed to have a bigger influence than just calorie counting. How those calories are processed (glucose versus fructose versus sucrose - all with potentially different mechanisms, from what I have learned) are treated differently by my body than how saturated fats are treated.
For example, there seems to be proof that saturated fat processing by the body sets the satiety signal more thoroughly than carbohydrate processing, and for longer duration. I feel less hungry, sated, so I eat less. And now when I eat, I focus more on the inclusiveness/variety of the source foods to make sure I am getting a more rounded spectrum of vitamins, minerals, and other vital components our bodies seem to require for good health.
It has so far been a fun experiment, unlike other attempts I have made in the past.