They didn't just pick a random IP and then send a team.
They picked the IP, sniffed their traffic, monitored their internet behaviour, read their forum posts, and then finally selected them to be an example.
By performing surveillance like this you can be 99% sure who is a real voluntary participant and who is just a stooge. A voluntary participant will talk about it on forums for example, brag on IRC, etc etc. These will be the ones selected by the FBI for dramatic home visits.