You can argue that asset prices should be derived from future cash flows, and hence, both Bitcoin and gold should be almost worthless. But that has nothing to do with the formula for computing any entity's market cap
Yes it is...
> The market cap for any security, by definition, is price-per-security number-of-securities.*
How do you think you get the price-per-security for a stock? If Apple has $100B in cash, why is their Market Cap $1.2T?
This is why people are skeptical of most things crypto... it really seems like there's hardly anyone in the community who understand fundamental financial concepts.
> You can argue that asset prices should be derived from future cash flows, and hence, both Bitcoin and gold should be almost worthless.
No - I'd just argue that it's completely misleading to try and assign a "market cap" to any asset other than a security and that people who rely on them are doing so to mislead rather to inform.
In practice, the amount of cash a company has has nothing to do with its market capitalization. There are companies with low cash, major debt, and sky high valuations. Stocks are supposed to be valued by discounted cash flows, but that doesn’t mean they are, by any means. The future values of companies are highly subjective.
Technically, cash doesn’t factor into future cash flows so much as it does book or liquidation value.
> This is why people are skeptical of most things crypto... it really seems like there's hardly anyone in the community who understand fundamental financial concepts.
I would argue one reason people are skeptical (annoyed is probably a better word) of crypto because it is full of folks who purport to know fundamental and even advanced financial concepts who are actually deluding themselves.
Market cap is an equities concept. The market value of a series of bonds isn't the issuance's market cap. The notional value of all options on a symbol is only useful to operations/settlement folk.
For Bitcoin, "market cap" is meaningless. It's too thinly and opaquely traded. Better would be flow of funds, i.e. value of new money flowing into and out of the system.
Put another way, if you bought all the shares in a company, you'd have the company. If you bought all the bonds of a company, you'd own the debt. The aggregates have meaning. If you bought every Bitcoin in existence (or dollar, for that matter), you would have nothing.
That claim about "thinly" contradicts the numbers given in my post above.
Most Bitcoin volume is non-economic [1]. Some of it is fraudulent printing. Some of it is wash trading.
That said, I don't doubt Binance's figures. The problem with taking a few trades and multiplying it by the outstanding coinage goes back to the aggregate being meaningless.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/comments/sr-nysearca-2019-01/srnysearca2...
However, if you believe Binance's figures then these figures alone are sufficient to support Bitcoin's current market cap in the sense that its volume / market cap is about the same as for well-traded stocks from S&P500. In other words, the claim that the volume is too small is not well supported because it is as small as for other financial assets, e.g., between 0.2-1% of market cap per day.
You're defending a metric by citing the metric.
The only utility for market cap with Bitcoin would appear to be to make arguments like this one. Comparing a nonsensical ratio to a similarly-sounding meaningful one. To someone who isn't thinking through what the numbers and their resulting ratios mean, I suppose it sounds authoritative.
Is it an insult, Arnav? Thousands of scientists use my research and they would probably disagree that I am "someone who isn't thinking through what the numbers and their resulting ratios mean".
The product of Bitcoin's price and its current circulation is financially meaningless. It's meaningless for fundamental reasons. (It’s even more meaningless to compare it to an equity market cap.)
That doesn't mean it is useless. People talk about it because it's a marketable metric. But so is community-adjusted Ebitda or the theoretical value of a comet's mineral wealth derived from multiplying its mass by the latest commodity trade.
These are narrative tools. Not analytic ones. Both are okay, but they have different roles.
I agree mcap is meaningless just like they mcap of USD/EUR/GOLD etc. It doesn't matter if is large or small it just has no meaning just like the price per unit has no meaning. Mcap is just a multiplication of the price.
Who claimed the opposite?
Which points to what IMO underpins whatever Bitcoin's underlying value is: a fear - or for some a hope - that typical vehicles investments will have precipitously declining future cash flow.
In that way it's like gold (minus the part about being pretty and useful for selling overpriced audio cables - is that still a thing?).
Unlike gold, though, it's in a way harder to secure, either by individuals or governments, because it isn't held behind physical security measures. Rather it's subject to the same large scale attacks as any other information on the Internet.
Right, but that's essentially a lazy re-definition of the term. I get that it's a bit wordy to always say, "the current total value of all bitcoins is $X billion", but market cap is specifically about the total value of a security's outstanding shares. If people want bitcoin to be treated seriously as a currency, they should stop using terms that explicitly refer to non-currencies.
To put it another way, no one would reasonably talk about something like the "market cap of the Euro"[0], so why would you do that for something else claimed to be a currency?
[0] Entertainingly, when I search "euro currency market cap", most of the results that come up are related to cryptocurrency.
Oh, but they do:
https://www.dailysabah.com/finance/2017/12/06/bitcoin-renews...
And while Market Cap may be on its surface misleading, its mere semantics, and is really in reference to what you've described; its just that as you said, its a currency and itself cannot have a strict Market-Cap but its a succinct way to describe the totality of its valuation for all issued satoshi's--which again, is misleading because of the 21 Million, its likely several million are lost forever.
Semantics are important. Often perception and optics are just as important as reality. Something that's been a hard lesson for me several times in life...
This can be computed as number-of-coins x price-per-coin.