I'm unsure how you're reaching this conclusion. I said nothing about eliminating capital gains and moving to some kind of system where investors are taxed on yearly stock price fluctuations. All I proposed was to forbid companies from purchasing their own stock for the purpose of manipulating its price upward.
Dividends exist and have a long history as being the the way of returning cash to shareholders. Forcing their use for that purpose would make it easier to make and enforce policies on that activity.