You're literally describing manipulating price by manipulating supply. If companies aren't buying back their stock to make its price go up, why are they buying it? You're contradicting yourself.
> Buybacks has many advantages though. The biggest one is that if you want to reinvest dividends into stock you would have to pay taxes which creates a situation where you are liable for taxes even if you didn't make any money (if the price fluctuates). Buyback is like automatically reinvested dividend. I don't think it should be taxable for the reasons outlined above.
I understand that stock buybacks have advantages in certain situations for some people. I'm suggesting those advantages be eliminated.