> “I am skeptical of the ability to license advanced nuclear reactors and deploy them on a scale that would make a difference for climate change,” adds Fetter. “But I think it’s worth exploring because they’re a centralized form of carbon-free electricity and we don’t have a lot of those available.” At least in the US, it might be the only way nuclear power gets another chance.
I think that's a fair assessment. It's probably not going to make a lot of difference but it is still interesting to explore and invest in.
Regarding solar and battery, mass production capacity is basically the biggest hurdle here. Demand seems to be taking care of that (i.e. people are building so-called Giga factories to take care of this) but we're still an order of magnitude or two off to take care of most of our needs. Just the process of ramping up production is going to cut cost further. And of course at the current price levels, battery + solar is already highly competitive with just about everything else. Of course in the process of ramping up production, there are likely to also going to be massive technical improvements that will further drive down cost and performance.
And just to pre-empt the argument: darkness is temporary and local, which means it is much less of a problem than some nuclear proponents seem to claim. Basically, if your panels don't provide enough power when it is cloudy, install more. If your battery runs out in the middle of the night, buy a bigger battery. If the area you live in is susceptible to extended periods of darkness (aka. the polar night), import power using cables. On the other hand, if, like most of the population of planet Earth, you live closer to the equator this is not going to be an issue.
Nuclear is still going to be useful but just not as our primary source of electricity. The safety and securitt concerns alone would make this impractical. Even if we can deliver this technically and produce these things cost effectively, you'd still need a lot of security measures to prevent people from doing silly things like creating dirty bombs with the nasty stuff inside. Imagine a few tens of thousands of these things, it would be a nightmare from a security point of view.
Though even now we aren’t independent when it comes to heating over the winters. We have to import oil, gas and coal. But with those one can have strategic stockpiles to last over the next/current winter at least if things go bad. Kind of similar for nuclear fuel. We have stockpiles for years but don’t mine it here (we could but economically much cheaper to buy from Sweden and Russia). Just much easier to stockpile that stuff.
But yeah for the vast majority of the whole planets population solar with batteries should work just fine.
The one large difference is that food is easier to import. But I am pretty sure we can solve the energy long distance trade problems.
But cloudy weather isn't. Ultimately that's the problem with doing a straight cost comparison between solar and wind. You have to build much more capacity to account for times when they aren't producing at 100%.
Boreal countries will be energy ghettos in a solar powered world.
TVO Teollisuuden voima (heavy industries power) is the company that built, operators and owns half of the nuclear plants in Finland (one of the owners of TVO owns the rest)
If they can get the financing from private markets to build more I say let them. None of the current/future plants were built with government money outside of them being the backer for the insurance.
I doubt prices will never reach $0.01/kWh. At least here in Finland transmissions fees are a larger part of the bill then the energy itself already. So unless every plant builds an absolutely massive solar farm next to it (and never plans to sell its overproduction from the day) the network fees alone will be much more then that.
The people left behind will be the poor who can’t afford to relocate and the excessively wealthy who don’t care about living expenses.
I think your position there is showing a thinly cloaked racism. I suspect much anti-solar talk has that as a motivation. The idea that white skinned boreal countries will become the future's "third world" may be intolerable.
The third world is characterized by not having, for example, a functioning transportation infrastructure. If Finland can't realistically charge their cars from solar and their choice is between paying somewhat more per kWh than Venezuela by using nuclear or some other non-photovoltaic power generation method vs. not continuing to have a transportation infrastructure, they're not going to stop having a transportation infrastructure.
And it's a damn stretch to frame this as a racial issue. You can expect places like India and Mexico to benefit from cheap solar, but only to about the same extent as "white people" places like the US and Australia. You would have to be an especially silly racist to hang your racial animus on solar power when you can reasonably expect more of the industry to set up shop in Arizona than Zimbabwe.
https://www.datagraver.com/thumbs/1300x1300r/2016-09/density...
Space exploration has in the past provided us with lots of information that we can use to understand our own climate and planetary systems. Not only that, but the often mentioned advances in material sciences and other areas might end up helping us much more than the sunk cost at the beginning.
I think we need a good mix of both.
https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/design-cert/nuscal...
There's some hand-waving on safety issues in Table 1.9-2. NuScale passes the buck on flooding issues to the plant owner. Also, there's some hand-waving on software safety issues: "The NuScale design applies RG 1.152, Revision 3 and IEEE Std. 7-4.3.2-2003 that it endorses. For RG 1.168, the requirements of IEEE 1012-2004 are tailored to the NuScale I&C development lifecycle, which is different from the conceptual waterfall lifecycle in IEEE 1012-2004. The applicable tasks from IEEE 1012-2004 to the I&C development are mapped. Some administrative mandatory requirements in the standard conflict with established Engineering or QA documentation requirements. The requirements of IEEE 1028-2008 are tailored to the NuScale I&C development lifecycle." This may mean "We use Agile and your outdated rules don't apply".
The key concept is that, since these plants are passively cooled and don't require pumps for cooling, many of the concerns about keeping cooling water flowing to prevent a meltdown don't apply. "For the NuScale design, the safety analysis shows that core damage does not occur during any design basis event.", says the application. What could possibly go wrong?
A big concern is that NuScale proposes to put up to 12 reactors in one connected pool. I haven't found the part yet where they discuss what happens if one leaks and contaminates the whole pool. Or the pool springs a leak and drains into the ground.
These are not small plants. A 12-unit plant is 720MW of electrical power, so it's getting close to a typical gigawatt sized plant. More small units, instead of one big one.
The history of power reactor meltdown incidents is roughly as follows:
- Three Mile Island - meltdown, big containment vessel, fully contained, expensive but not hazardous.
- Chernobyl - fire, meltdown, no containment vessel, radioactive material dispersed over large area.
- Fukishima - meltdowns, undersized containment vessels breached, radioactive material dispersed over moderate sized area.
A certain amount of skepticism about designs that "don't need" a big containment vessel is perhaps justified.
Look at the IMSR.
You can find leaks in pools pretty easy by using a double lining and distributed sensors or in closed environments like this, by measuring net flows and looking out for any net change in volume.
A NuScale press release does say that. "The system is capable of providing 30 days of cooling without adding water to the pool."[2]
The web site hype goes even further: "Should it become necessary, NuScale’s SMR shuts itself down and self-cools for an indefinite period of time, with no operator action required, no additional water, and no AC or DC power needed."[3] But that's not what the NRC filing says.
Looks like they make bigger claims when they think they can get away with it.
[1] https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1924/ML19241A398.pdf [2] https://newsroom.nuscalepower.com/sites/nuscalepower.newshq.... [3] https://www.nuscalepower.com/
The 30 day claim was published in January 2012 in response to the Fukushima accident: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.13182/NT12-A13556
Also, in "NuScale Technical Report Long-Term Cooling Methodology, dated January 2017, TR-0916-51299" (https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1835/ML18355A973.pdf)
"5.3.4 Long Term Cooling Evaluation Period LTC analysis is limited to three days. This timeframe is considered acceptable because: (1) the most severe conditions will have been captured within the 72 hour window analyzed, and any conditions that could reasonably be expected to occur beyond this time period are thus bounded by the 72 hour calculation, and (2) after 72 hours, operator actions can be credited. When realistic initial operating levels, temperatures, and decay heat are considered, the scope of the LTC analyses bound the expected level decrease in the reactor pool ultimate heat sink over 30 days, for up to twelve modules transferring decay and residual heat to the reactor pool."
I read this as that they ran a number of scenarios with extreme initial conditions and at the end of three days all operating characteristics were effectively the same as with typical starting conditions and therefore they expected the 30 day simulations would give the same result no matter what the initial conditions were. I don't think they are hiding anything here.
The thing with nuclear reactors is that this sentence was thought to be true for most designs, including those that failed to varying degrees (RBMK, GE BWR, B&W PWR).
Cost is not really relevant to energy because the entire human civilization requires energy to function.
Also, renewables can barely compete with nuclear, because they cannot deliver enough energy when you need it. Renewables also require more metals and mining, so they emit more.
The coal and natural gas industry likes renewables because coal is on-demand energy.
Cost must be properly accounted for, of course, including externalities.
Generally it's pretty complicated to evaluate the public interest, and I don't think you can put a price tag on public interest.
It doesn't change the fact that nuclear is always better. It's just that private funding doesn't like it because it's a very long term investment.
I understand why nuclear fans want to say cost doesn't matter. If cost matters, nuclear sucks. I understand how jarring this new reality (that nuclear has been priced out of the market vs. other CO2-free alternatives) is. Nuclear fans are still in denial about it, but declaring the falsehood "nuclear is always better" doesn't change that reality.
I had this argument several times.
Can you power electrical trains with renewables? No, because you can't decide when to have wind or sun.
Concerning costs, this consultants made difference estimation and even when he favors renewables, they are still 2 times more expensive that nuclear.
Even someone who worked with the Obama administration for renewables realized nuclear was better.
But renewables have rendered this design obsolete.
Now, the cheaper sources are not baseload, but intermittent. The optimal grid design is become one of using intermittent sources, then filling in around those with some combination of storage and dispatchable supplies. Expensive baseload has no place anymore in this situation.
Your claim that renewables are 2x the cost of nuclear is an easily checked falsehood. The levelized cost of energy from renewables is 3-4x less than new nuclear plants.
Essentially, it means renewables = coal+gas. Not so good for low emissions.
Renewable + heat/cold storage + electricity storage + demand-response + energy efficiency = that can deliver enough energy when you need it (and probably much cheaper than with nuclear)
Really? I thought it requires a large investment that has a big impact on the environment which is an external cost to energy production and usually people do not care about it. Unless we are able to produce mass amounts of superconductive materials and deploy this solution to replace traditional infrastructure we have a wasteful way of transporting energy.
http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-...
[On nuclear fusion] “It's kind of as instructive to ask what's not the problem as it is to ask what is the problem. There is a problem. The problem is not cost. It's not that energy generation technologies are expensive. The cost is lower than it has ever been to generate electricity.
It's also not intermittency, and there are a lot of studies out there looking at getting to very high penetration of renewables, and how you manage that grid with those intermittent sources, and the answers sort of range between, let's say, 60% penetration of renewables to 100% penetration. I can't argue about that, but fundamentally I think it is possible to manage that grid and, even more so, the cost of doing so is not prohibitive.
[A consultancy called Systemic] added on the cost of intermittency, basically paid for with lithium ion batteries and gas peakers to deal with the hardest intermittencies to deal with—which is not when the sun goes in front of a cloud, but when it's summer or winter, that difference. So this isn't a carbon-neutral grid, it still has gas in it, but the total cost of intermittency adds about $15/MWh to the levelized cost.
So you take solar, for example, from 35 to 50. Well, gas costs 80, so this doesn't change the picture. Solar and wind are still the cheapest sources of electricity.
The problem, and this is where fusion fits, and this is where any new energy technology fits; the problem is scale. This is looking at the growth in deployment of solar and wind in a global sense. [...] This is the total sum of wind and solar based on current policies. We wanted the most aggressive scenario for the deployment of solar and wind, because we wanted to know the answer to the question: do we actually need fusion? So we took these curves, this is continued exponential growth. We did this last year; reality is already behind this model, because last year, 2018, growth in renewables flatlined for the first time. We assumed continual exponential growth. You add all of that up and you compare it to the total demand for electricity.
[...] Renewables can get us to half the required electricity generation. A lot of the stories you see in news take that number and compare it to how much electricity we need now, but you know electric cars are coming, right?, electricity demand is going to increase. If we're going to get to net zero, whilst overall energy consumption might be falling, the demand for electricity is substantially rising because actually only about 20% of energy is electricity, so, you know, the energy in my car I drove here this morning was not electricity.
That is what creates this clean power gap and this is why ultimately we need new technologies. We cannot get to the scale required to meet net zero by 2050 with the technologies that we currently have.”
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/global-solar-pv...
Figure 20% of peak for 24/7 power production (using nonexistent cheap storage) and you get 25GW capacity installation per year for solar.
Meanwhile: "Over 100 power reactors with a total gross capacity of about 120,000 MWe are on order or planned, and over 300 more are proposed."
https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-an...
So, globally I think nuclear can give solar a run for its money, although in some countries nuclear may not be an option due to public opposition or access to the technology.
We have 25GW/year vs. 120GW/? years. If you scroll to the bottom table, and sum a few numbers you get:
2020: 15MWe
2021: 7MWe
2022: 8MWe
2023: 8MWe"The growth flatlined" is a pretty confusing phrasing. What does it mean, that the trajectory is only parabolic? (Their graphic does certainly not look linear.) Things can not stay exponential forever, besides, let's ignore that this is a single data point on the crazy noisy area that is economics.
But anyway, is that really a talk saying we should invest in fusion because solar won't scale fast enough?
> But anyway, is that really a talk saying we should invest in fusion because solar won't scale fast enough?
Yes.
There's no magic to fusion, it's just a matter of finding a way to do it economically.
None of those have any real chance of being commercial viable. The tokamak approaches, in particular, are both much larger than, and much more complex than, a fission reactor of equal power output. Yes, they are more cost effective than ITER. Only 40x lower power density vs. 400x lower. Yay?
Even if you have to replace a piece, you just unfold, crane the old one out, and crane the new one in.
The core of a fission reactor of a given power output should be smaller and simpler than that of a fusion reactor. As a result, it should be much cheaper, and also more reliable.
The parts outside will be very similar (even fusion reactors will require containment buildings, due to the very large amounts of tritium involved).
Fusion designs go even further and imagine operating at high temperature than LWRs. But this also drives up cost; materials problems rapidly become worse as temperatures increase. High temperature fission reactors have never caught on, for this reason.
It follows that fusion power plants will not be cheaper than fission power plants.
Fusion requires fewer safeguards, less insurance, and is more repairable than fission. Reliability isn't an issue just because it's 4m³.
Why would fusion reactors need ‘very large’ tritium supplies? SPARC would use, what, <100g/day? And it would generate excess, so they wouldn't need a stockpile. Tritium isn't even particularly dangerous; it goes away on its own, and doesn't stick around in biological systems.
I don't believe these estimates, either in the input data or the methodology. They are basically an exercise in "how optimistic can I be before no one believes me". It's not as if any shenanigans in them will be checked against reality anytime soon. They aren't a good counter to the simple argument of "larger, more complex, and made of more exotic materials implies more expensive."
But in any case, let's look at ARC, shall we? The cost comes to $29/W(e), very much higher than fission reactors. They have to resort to "and the Nth of a kind plant will be a factor of K cheaper". Never mind that the closest analogy, nuclear fission plants, has not shown good experience effects.
About tritium: I don't think you grasp how problematic this material is. The amount of tritium consumed in a 1 GW(e) fusion plant in a year would be enough to contaminate 2 months worth of the flow of the Mississippi River, at New Orleans, above the legal limit for drinking water. Confinement of tritium is going to have to be damned near perfect for a DT reactor to be acceptable.
So you build a bunch of panel factories, sell panels to Arizona and pay off most of the fixed costs of building those factories. But then the markets willing to pay higher prices get saturated. Once you've sold them as many panels as they need, they already have them and stop buying as many. Lower demand. So by supply and demand, the price comes down.
That's good -- now you're competitive in Northern California and people start buying panels there. But it's also bad -- it's profitable to keep operating your existing factories which are already built, but at the lower price it's not as profitable to build new ones. Eventually the price gets low enough that production capacity stops growing.
You can use the existing production capacity to get to 100% eventually, but if you wanted to do it faster you would need higher prices to justify building more factories. Only then there would be less demand, so you still can't increase the growth rate.
Nuclear comes at it from the other end. Can't compete with solar in Phoenix for the daytime peak but it can in Toronto for baseload. Which means there is greater demand for solar for some uses and greater demand for nuclear for other uses, and you replace carbon faster when you build both at once.
https://www.thestar.com/business/2009/07/14/26b_cost_killed_...
And it's a bit silly to argue against doing things that make it more cost effective to build something (improving regulatory efficiency, increasing production scale) by arguing that it costs too much to build. The whole idea is that if we did the things then it wouldn't cost as much.
These NuScale reactors cost less (even per MW) than that bid in Ontario, do they not?
What was notable about that process was the province required bidders to taking on risks that the province would not back. The only bidder willing to do that (Areva bid but did not do so, so their bid was not compliant) priced the cost of the risk into the bid.
This demonstrated that, properly priced, nuclear is far out of the running economically. It only gets built when the risks are forced on others (taxpayers, ratepayers) outside a fair competitive process.
In retrospect, this should have been a serious warning that other new builds in the "nuclear renaissance" were extremely risky, as they turned out to be.
Given this history, I would believe NuScale only after they've built their Nth-of-a-kind system on budget and aren't bankrupt.
The problem with these risk calculations is that you're asking a private insurance company to issue a very large policy with a small probability of payout. The major cost of those policies isn't actually in the risk itself, it's the cost of holding enough capital in reserve to be able to satisfy the policy size independent of the risk probability. They're not allowed to just invest that money in the stock market, so you're essentially paying them to forego the market rate of return on a huge pile of money for the entire term of the policy, even if no claim is ever filed.
That's why it's typically a government providing the insurance in these cases -- they're not required to hold the money in reserve so they don't have to effectively pay interest to hold money that might never actually have to be paid out.
Also notice that the competition there still wasn't solar, it was fossil fuels. And if you want to talk about pricing in the that risk then nuclear looks very attractive.
And the problem with the opposite is that risk is foisted off on unwilling consumers. The bidding process is subverted.
If risk is placed on the groups selling the technology, they have an incentive to work on technologies that are inherently less risky. Renewables, for example, typically come in within 10% of the bid price. Yet you would not allow this risk advantage to have any place in the decision process by subsidizing nuclear's risk.
It isn't the consumers who take on the risk, it's the government. But nobody's asking them to do it for free, just charge an actuarially honest insurance premium that doesn't include having to effectively pay interest on a giant reserve fund even if it's never used.
> If risk is placed on the groups selling the technology, they have an incentive to work on technologies that are inherently less risky.
And yet they would still be stymied by a similar requirement.
Consider that solar panels have some nasty stuff in them. Heavy metals. That's well and good so long as they stay inside like they're supposed to and then get properly recycled, but what's the worst case scenario? Maybe something like a major hail storm that cracks open the panels, followed by severe acid rain that leeches the metal into the soil and the groundwater, or maybe a big forest fire that burns them and releases the toxins into the air.
A 1GW solar farm would have something like a million panels, so tens of millions of pounds of material, maybe a hundred million. If they all burned, the cloud could spread over a huge area, or pollute the soil and groundwater for millions of people. So all I ask is for you to have to carry $200,000,000,000 worth of insurance just in case that happens. The worst case is really bad but the probability of that happening is pretty low, so you won't have any trouble finding someone to write a policy that size and whoever you do find will give you a good rate, right?
Assuming risks like that is what governments do. If your giant solar farm burns to a crisp and you go bankrupt, they're the ones who will have to make it a superfund site, clean it up and bail everyone out.
Doing the same thing with nuclear isn't a special subsidy, it's standard operating procedure across all industries. Requiring nuclear plants to account for every last penny of risk or externality is fine if they're going to do the same thing for everybody else, but they don't. So are we going to require everybody to insure against the worst case scenario, or not?
Typical solar cells are made of glass/ceramics so they don't actually burn and the cleanup should actually be manageable.
Doesn't that mean we should prohibit operating it at scale until we have some better data on the risks of operating it at scale? Or at least require you to carry the insurance in the meantime, say for six to twelve decades?
Isolated demands for rigor can make anything too expensive to be competitive.
On that metric, we know renewables are far less risky. They typically come in within 10% of the bid.
As for new tech, 1366 Technologies has built a factory in Malaysia and was expected to ramp up their kerf-less wafer production in Q3 2019 for sale to Hanwha at their neighboring plant.
https://1366tech.com/2019/02/26/1366-technologies-and-hanwha...
Meanwhile, another of my favorite companies, AltaDevices has recently shut down and is looking for new investors.
https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2019/12/09/alta-devices-hopes-ou...
I am certainly hopeful that eventually new capacity will come online that can compete with existing factories, but the fact remains that numbers from a linear programming model do not mean that the factories exist to build all that solar.
"Solar PV capex trending at US$9 billion annually as new GW fabs in China slash investments required"
https://www.pv-tech.org/editors-blog/solar-pv-capex-trending...
China is where the ecosystem of experienced manufacturers, material suppliers, and manufacturing equipment suppliers all comes together now. The rest of the world's solar manufacturers are struggling because the Chinese ones have such economies of scale that it's difficult to compete head-on. (Barring perhaps First Solar. First Solar is still doing ok because it has achieved multi-gigawatt manufacturing scale too, and because its product has advantages when operating in high temperature conditions. Also there are a few other solar manufacturers that can weather the storm because they're part of large conglomerates, like LG.)
Non-Chinese solar manufacturers like to cry "unfair competition" at low Chinese solar prices, but after reading industry trade publications for several years I am skeptical of that argument. To me it looks like Chinese PV companies did get government protection and incentives to establish themselves, but no worse than Western countries give to their own favored industries. And now they can produce good products at unbeatable prices. Not a whole lot different from Japan overtaking American radio and TV manufacturers in decades past, or (more recently) China rapidly overtaking incumbents to become the world's largest lithium ion battery manufacturer.
If you try to scale up factories for faster growth you will have to start shutting them down when you hit an oversupply after 5-10 years and then where will your replacement cells come from?
BTW, the argument being made here against renewables would apply equally well against nuclear. Hail Mary Reactors will also require scaling up of factories to make them.
Current trend is that solar+battery won’t be useful for a long time. Solar with current trends currently has no hope of replacing base-load because the storage options are terrible.
It's like comparing ICE vs battery electric vehicles on the basis of what's best for the non engine/motor parts, or "base-car".
People need a whole car and a whole energy system. Coal and nuclear, which are suited to this artifical contstruct of baseload, are not good for providing 100% of energy requirements on their own or in partnership with others and that's why no one is building them anymore.