Hacker News Reader

Probably refers to the "Uncle Sam Doesn't Need You!" chapter in "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman", in which Feynman is given a psychiatric evaluation as part of the medical exam for the draft. Anecdotally, he came away with an even lower opinion of psychiatry (rightly or wrongly) than he had when he went in.

View on HN

I seem to recall Feynman having a similar attitude towards philosophy.

It's really sad and disapopinting to see that sort of close-minded attitude come from such a talented person towards entire fields he knows nearly nothing about.

A point to make is mid 20th century psychiatry and philosophy were hot garbage.

That's a matter of opinion, one which I personally disagree with, though I am not a fan of some of the philosophy and psychology of the 20th Century.

Furthermore, philosophy extends back thousands of years and spans across many societies and cultures. To dismiss all of it in a handwavy way from a position of ignorance, as Feynman did, speaks of nothing but narrow-minded bigotry.

I'm not dismissing all of philosophy. I'm dismissing mid 20th century philosophy.

Even then, mid 20th century philosophy is a pretty broad category. It contains stuff like Derrida but also contains stuff like Quine.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com