Here are some examples:
1. How close are you with this person? An issue of trust.
2. What is the context? Friends, coworker, interview, etc.
3. What is the goal? Friendship, small-talk, debate, etc.
4. Who is the audience? student, foreigner, church, etc.
I suspect your wife asks these questions to the religious ("theology"), which is a subset (bias). It is risky to ask controversial issues today to people not with your value system, so I also suspect she became more sensitive after trial and error. The best way is to ask her directly.
Please confirm/refute my hypotheses.