I’m not arguing that a PhD is a meaningless credential, rather that the drop-off in employability (for most things that aren’t faculty jobs) from “PhD holder” to “dropped out after quals, but did some research and can code” is much smaller than the drop off between “MD” and “dropped out of med school, but knows some medicine”. So the gap in attrition rates isn’t solely a function of a better or worse experience.
I still think it’s good to try to keep people who get PhDs, especially in areas I think are important, like machine learning research.
But I agree that making a PhD an even more useful credential is unlikely to increase the quality of the PhD experience itself.