Edited to remove reddit comparison.
Edited to remove reddit comparison.
'superkuh could very well have been downvoted for commenting on downvotes contrary to the guidelines, rather than for anything about the other content (which otherwise looks fine).
> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
The guideline is there specifically to prevent threads like this, devolving into meta discussion rather than focussing on the submission. Post constructive comments, (silently) give compensatory upvotes to those you think are wrongly downvoted, and move along.
It just becomes frustrating to see this pattern of behavior and how pronounced it has become. I frequently disagree with comments but they often generate good discussion. This is how we all get smarter. Instead, the potential is deterred by downvotes.
Many of us have family members fighting cancer, and there are cancer patients and survivors reading HN. I don't think a casual statement equating that terrible disease with a mere programming language is appropriate here or in any public forum.
By way of contrast, I would have upvoted a comment like this:
I avoid JavaScript whenever I can. I feel safer that way. I use FooBlock Organic to selectively whitelist JavaScript for sites that need it and that I trust. I recognize the irony of using a browser extension which is itself written in JavaScript, but it's open source and I've reviewed the source code carefully. I even contributed some patches to make it easier to use.
That’s about as helpful as saying the best way to avoid being tracked is by not using the web.
So, since you say disabling JS is infeasible.. to what extent? What websites work with JS disabled, what might I miss out on? Is it possible to compromise, perhaps a browser can be configured to whitelist certain JS APIs? Perhaps we create a JS-lite standard? I don't know. Let's talk about it though.
I like that kind of discussion. It is worth noting that I have always had JS enabled, but I would like to hear the opinions and perspectives of everyone.
If you don’t accept JS, nothing renders.
It would be nice if at least, the only way to be able to downvote, would be to also post (require) a comment.