Flip it around, "Why would I spend resources on you if the chance that you're going to generate a return on those resources is minimal?"
Sign-in with Apple does not make sense as a product with the goal of direct profit, (and the majority of its developer target market already pays, because they only implement it because it's an requirement for them building their apps), so this logic doesn't work so well.
Also, my comment was addressing the direct parent comment, not the entire thread above it.
An example would be free/paid website, where you constantly are trying to automate and improve the free version with features that used to be paid
You are free to choose how to run your biz of course and the market will decide how valuable your idea is, and judging from your experience it sounds like it makes you money, which is a good thing :)
A business is interested in profit. Apple is no different. If you're not paying in, they're directly incentivized to make your experience suck as much as they can without crossing legal lines, to get you to do so.
I'm not saying I want to be in the fee-gating communities, I agree with you on that point. I'm just saying expecting a multi-billion dollar corporation to be interested in fostering that same sense of community is ridiculous.
You're right that a community is not a business. That's ultimately the fundamental rot in capitalism.