I find it really troublesome that Google is allowed to blatantly lie to their consumers about the required permission by implying the app is utterly broken while it actually still works. Next year I'm going for an iPhone but as I can see it's not the promise Land yet.
It's not a "blatant lie" if it actually breaks APIs.
Lack of this is one of those recurring struggles how you know the software isn't written any more for the benefit of the end user. There is no reason for this adversarial position (well, there is, but it has to do with you as a product, not a user).
So it's a very minor inconvenience that you now have to type a few digits from an SMS instead of that happening automatically.
My prediction: If people stop allowing this feature becomes even slightly popular, they're gonna use longer codes "for security".
It was deemed important enough that Apple followed by implementing the API in iOS12.
Funnily, I wasn't able to read the linked post easily with my web browser privacy features (well, noscript) enabled.
I think generally it's a bad idea to impose whatever one perceives as "good" on others. And if a user doesn't care and understand what's going on, merely restricting some of the spyware they currently have on an Internet-connected device with private information on it wouldn't even protect privacy much: I think (based on a couple of times I've observed the process on Android smartphones) they had to allow all that access on installation in the first place.
The much more likely outcome is that you’ll be marked as the odd duck in the family, and they’ll make a mental note to not let you handle their devices in the future.
If the goal is to make people care more about privacy (or really anything), an approach that breaks existing workflows and shrugs off that breakage as being a good thing isn’t really a winning approach.
My family already cares about privacy, they just find it incredibly hard to navigate the maze of settings and figure out what you can disable and what is hiding somewhere doing nasty useless shit.
When I disable a setting for them, I ask if they use the feature, explain what it does. Or in many cases, we look it up together, because DAMN they made that shit hard to understand.
I also ask what apps they use, and if I know any, suggest alternatives.
Usually they're happy to get rid of a couple of useless apps that were giving notifications and other screen spam.
In general they're happy that I help them. It's ridiculous that I have to, because my family is not dumb and they want to figure it out, it's just that if you don't deal with this shit every day, it's just a swamp and you tend to throw your hands in the air and give up.
That can be a blessing in disguise. :)
Unless you have access to an infinite pool of IPs and mobile numbers and rotate at frequent but random interval (and get your friends to do so as well especially with their numbers) it's basically impossible.
Better just not use scummy apps and services. If they can't be bothered to respect your privacy then find something else which can. You might need to pay for it but at least your privacy is safer.