Reason, for me is probably the most intuitive application I have used since I initially was plugging hardware cables to make music. However, it certainly isn't the most efficient way to patch something, but with the huge amount of routing flexibility in that software, I don't see a better option, the context menu for cable patching isn't really an effective method either since its list can exceed the height of my screen in some cases. I find though that most audio applications(reason included) do offer very flexible and easy linkage to hardware controllers which makes life easier. Most audio processing is about hands on control of many parameters simultaneously, and I think some of the best solutions(jazz mutant had some purpose built touch control surfaces) were much too expensive for the average user. I really hope that someone can make a tablet based app equivalent for iOS/android that could mimic these types of things. <shameless plug> (any software vendors want a dev(me) who would LOVE to work on this sorta project?!?! :)</shameless plug>
One other point that wasnt addressed properly in this article is that much of the "hardware look" UI chrome is due to these things being "emulations" of real gear. I think the market has decided that if you want to model a piece of gear, you had better draw up a photo-realistic picture of it and add some 3dfx to the knobs and sliders. For better or worse, a lot of users just dont buy into the sound emulation thing unless it looks like real device.
I have seen a lot of developers out there that have made some very functional very pretty UIs that also look like gear. U-he, FXPansion come to mind. Interestingly, Logic contains some very clean and easy to use UIs(the included efx) along with the dogs like Sculpture and Ultrabeat. Hopefully Logic10 will have a UI refresh to improve things...