- He called garbage code garbage.
- He pointed out that most of people don't understand locking.
- He again pointed out that almost no one including him is qualified enough to write own locking code.
There is absolutely no personal attacks or whatever. It's just someone make a big fuss about how bad kernel is without real reasons and Linus called bullshit.
It sounds like there was an expectation that Linux should support something that it doesn't, and whether it _should_ support it is up for debate. Totally agree about Linus's involvement in any communities.
I assume part of it is that he feels personally attacked when something about Linux is challenged.
You really didn't paid attention to what being discussed. Someone started discussion on how bad Linux kernel is based on incorrect data generated by badly written code.
Ironically, if a manager or CEO or VC or politician used similar language, they would be attacked by the same people for being abusive and elitist. But when an alpha-programmer does it, it is somehow ok.
I've learnt so much from reading both the original blog post, and also the resulting conversation with Linus. The technical work Linus has done and is doing, is fantastic and to be commended. I just wish he followed through on his earlier desire to change his communication style.
a) He's aware of his tone, but probably bald tired of reading stuff that can be (and in this case is) perceived as an attack (the blog post's title comes to mind) on his work and a bad benchmark/study/conclusion is used to justify it? (Now imagine enduring this throughout decades... Yeah, one has to have very thick skin to be in such a position--have you ever tried to be in his shoes for a moment?)
b) He has called himself names as well (In the past I've seriously been tempted to compile a list of such self-deprecation behaviour but it's ultimately pointless); and
c) We don't know what's going on in his life or maybe it's just how he is or maybe it's a cultural thing.
My point is: sure Linus can do better on how to react to criticism, but inexperienced people ought to refrain themselves from blaming other people's work--especially from vastly experienced ones.