Another idea is to find someone who will sell you something at face value, that they also acquired for face value, such as silver bars or copper bars or something of that nature.
In that scenario, the person who originally sold the metal to the guy who sells it to you will have made a profit, but not a very big one after accounting for the expense they went through to obtain it. This is one way I can think of that avoids the technical illegality of defacing currency.
But I would definitely put the cash in a shredder or burn it. It will be quite difficult to prove what you did with the cash-- you can just say you spent it on consumable goods like food, drinks, vacations, blah blah :)