When was the last time you used a browser that had no javascript? When did you last time manually confirm a cookie?
User Experience trumps Graceful Degradation.
When was the last time you used a browser that had no javascript? When did you last time manually confirm a cookie?
User Experience trumps Graceful Degradation.
If you want to completely throw out search engine crawlers viewing your content, 508 compliance, and 5-10% of your visitors with Javascript disabled, then sure ignore Gracefully Degradation. Not to mention that Graceful Degradation is frowned upon to begin with, you should be Progressively Enhancing. Starting with a site deeply entrenched in spaghetti Javascript code and trying to make it work without it takes a ridiculous amount of time compared to just building the site without a single line of Javascript written to begin with, and just provide all the fancy features after you have a full, working site.
Thanks for the assessment. I'll put that on my resume next to the 10yrs of web work.
search engine crawlers
http://code.google.com/web/ajaxcrawling/docs/getting-started...
508 compliance
It may sounds harsh but most sites couldn't care less about accessibility because it's not required by law and because users with assistive devices don't account for a measurable portion of their revenue.
5-10% of your visitors with Javascript disabled
Not sure what kind of site you have there, my reports are more inline with what yahoo measures (i.e. hovering around 1%):
http://developer.yahoo.com/blogs/ydn/posts/2010/10/how-many-...
Starting with a site deeply entrenched in spaghetti Javascript code and trying to make it work without it takes a ridiculous amount of time compared to just building the site without a single line of Javascript written to begin with
Spoken like a true novice.
I'm not aware of anyone attempting to enforce this however.
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en...
Google, Yahoo, AOL, and several other major web companies all recommend Progressive Enhancement. But sure, you know better.
Sure, if you're building a content site, you will want to have progressive enhancement, but if you're building a client-side application, SEO concerns and the other concerns of content-delivery sites are less relevant.