This is not the comment to be fighting this battle with.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/08/business/media/teen-vogue... for those that are curious.
This is NOT the hill for citation fanatics to die on.
[edit] also another comment had already provided a citation, in fact the citation you provided, so you or I providing the citation was unnecessary so I don't understand your point
I'm sorry we didn't participate in this conversation in the manner you wanted us to.
>All the while we've learned that they have utterly sold the company to international electioneers.
This is disinformation, laundered with the trust of the first comment.
Facebook is behind getting the highest bidders elected all around the world.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2017-12-21/inside-th...
The ask was: "Citations to your references would be appreciated."
It's true that a citation is not needed, but including one adds value, in that it increases efficiency.
> Just disputing that a citation was appreciated for that claim in this forum.
There is no word to replace required that wouldn't be open to your complaint; e.g. needed, necessary,
Yes, a citation would always be appreciated, but it's gate keeping to ask people to always provide citations when not truly necessary.
Appreciated is an appropriate word, you subconsciously swapped in required.
A citation is required if the goal is to maximize constructive communication - if that's the goal, of course.
The original comment:
> Citations to your references would be appreciated. It's the first step to overcoming the state of internet disinformation, as well as helping society overcome the fear of missing out just because someone doesn't already know your references.
This request (and it's just that, nothing more) seems reasonable.
This subsequent comment exchange:
>> All the while we've learned that they have utterly sold the company to international electioneers.
> This is disinformation, laundered with the trust of the first comment.
...specifically: "laundered with the trust of the first comment" seems like perfectly valid criticism, and arguably adds to the "onus" (or value in) for the original person to provide a proper citation, in order to minimize misunderstanding.
And then here is where I see a problem arises:
> Just disputing that a citation was required for that claim in this forum.
You are criticizing someone for saying a citation is required, but it is you that introduced the idea of it being a requirement into the conversation - which is what I pointed out (perhaps not as eloquently as I should/could have).
Your subsequent reasoning:
> I deliberately swapped so you could see how that word doesn't work
...doesn't make sense to me. Replacing the original word with a new one that has a distinctly different meaning, and then criticizing OP for the new meaning of the sentence, doesn't make sense to me.
Am I misunderstanding somehow?
Words have distinct (non-interchangeable) and broadly accepted meanings, independent of either intent or personal preferences for what the meaning should be. I have merely interpreted your words according to the broadly accepted meanings, have I not?
When in Rome...