Hacker News Reader

The article that modernerd linked to has links at the bottom, in the "Appendix". The reviewer report is here: https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2014/11/review-form....

I love how everything other than the presentation is either Excellent or Very Good while the presentation is just Good.

I'm not sure whether that's the full report though.

The real review is better than my made-up review. The reviewer is probably intimately familiar with the problem described by the article's author.

If I was being spammed to review articles and saw this come through, I might be a little tempted to rubber-stamp it.

"The article makes a convincing argument that is supported by the data."