E.g, "...that's how open source works!"
That's your opinion, but what obligates the developer to adhere to this?
If the question is, was this a professionally run OSS project I would say, certainly not, and I assume almost everyone would agree. But so what? Why should a maintainer be expected to run an OSS project to a certain level of responsiveness or spin up a governance mechanism if they can't do it on their own?
> The obvious difference that I can see is the maintainer response to said criticisms.
I would suggest that reddit mobs are almost entirely capricious, random, and irrational.