I don't get why it ever needs to be on the internet even when it does have authentication. Surely the public/private subnet split is a common practice.
Hell, even if it is airgapped, it can still be compromised by viruses on USB sticks and such.
You should never be leaving sensitive systems wide open, period, regardless of how secure you might think that network is. Thousands of data breaches have been caused because networks didn't end up being as secure or as separated as hoped for.
If you get to the point where it’s what’s protecting your data, you’re already fundamentally screwed.