Then you have to (a) show why you weren't the one to encrypt the devices or (b) make a 5th Amendment argument about why you don't have to turn over the encryption key during which time you may be incarcerated. "I forgot" is generally not a valid defense.
Am I the only here who had to re-install Linux after x weeks or months of uptime because the LUKS password was forgotten? It happened to me more than once.
How is it "generally not" (but sometimes yes?) a valid defense when it's a fact that people are losing their passwords?
The internet is full of messages like: "I forgot my LUKS password but remember it had the name of my dog in it" (not advising to do that btw), "Is there a way to crack my own password?"
P.S: I've got backup of all my files and configuration files, so re-installing Linux ain't a problem: theft / flood / fire / full-disk encryption password lost... I wouldn't lose anything.
The number of times that people invoke "I don't recall" while giving testimony under oath says otherwise.
And for the record, a defendant claiming "they forgot" something within their control is valid circumstantial evidence of guilt or responsibility.
When claimed by the police or prosecution witness, it's just as much valid evidence against guilt, and has been used many times to get defendants off.
Basically, it's valid circumstantial evidence against the party/side that makes the claim of forgetfulness.
OTOH, if you were to argue that it's not your device, or that you weren't the person that encrypted it, that's a very different situation.
OTOH, if a witness forgets, they would not be held in court, because there's no benefit to them forgetting, and so their loss of memory is believable.
This ruling only says that the confinement period for contempt of court, where the court has order an individual to de-encrypt some data, is too long if it is more than 18 continuous months. This does not mean that after serving that sentence and upon subsequent release, that further refusal after another court order and hearing can not result in another sentence for contempt.
Try to think about it from the court's point of view. The truth could be:
A. You legitimately forgot.
B. You're lying.
I know which one Occam's Razor favors.
Yeah, I'd bet that most people claiming to have forgotten a key or password are lying. But so what? How do you differentiate those who're concealing vs. those that legitimately don't know the string of characters? If they float, they're a witch, if they sink, then I guess they're not? (That's what 18 months for contempt is akin to)
B. You're guilty.
Uh, this is the essential question to begin with. The judge doesn't decide this unless you're in clown court.
I do understand the meaning and most likely intent of your post, but the language used is less effective than it could be.
You don't want to go into any of those reasons people waive a jury, right?
Edit: I guess this case actually answers that, to some extent. Before he said he forgot the password, he tried a couple for them.