I don't think I have ethical issues with DDOS protection in general, but as someone who browses using Firefox on Linux with tracking blocking I know how annoying it can get. If I don't need it why bother? Plus I generally like to minimize opaque layers in my "stack".
And if you were using cloudflare before you should be okay with some people not being able to access your site since that's the norm there.
Yeaah, I don’t think anyone who’s operated a larger onion service would agree with you.
I've had one that's been under a DoS for about a month now and things are going well regardless. Differentiating "real" from "bad" traffic is super hard and almost infeasible, I get what you're saying about that. But in terms of not getting knocked offline Tor is easy and really nice.
That’s of course only until someone who isn’t utterly incompetent tries to DoS you and you realize that you’ll need to spin up hundreds and hundreds of tor daemons (with cpu cores to match!) to tank it.
Onionbalance isn’t built in, and hardly solves attacks. There are no DDoS protection services, so you’re left scrambling to build your own infra against impossible odds.
None of the big onionland sites manage decent uptimes.