Don't make the perfect the enemy of the good. A union-negotiated contract that's better than the one you'd get without the union is, well, better. It might not be "fair" or flawless, but it's still better.
It doesn't always work, in some industries I can see the relationship is much more confrontational and damaging, but it doesn't have to be that way.
Considering that many, many countries exist where this is the case (most of the time), this seems to be very well founded.
> Hermes: So you're telling me I could fire my whole staff and hire Grunka Lunkas at half the cost?
> Glurmo: That's right. They think they have a good union but they don't. [whispering] They're basically slaves.