What's happening under the hood is mostly fine (mostly, because git completely breaks down with large binary files, and solutions like git lfs don't help much with this problem).
What's really bad is the git "frontend", that there's no obvious standard workflow, instead there's a thousand ways to do the same thing. That's great if you have a lot of time for tinkering and meddling with the tools layer, but not when you simply need to get shit done. The version control system should essentially 'disappear' and never require attention.