Facebook sent them a list.
No-one said anything about manually checking every name until you did.
Facebook sent them a list.
No-one said anything about manually checking every name until you did.
One can just ask for them to divulge the names (FB did that); one can refuse to divulge the names (Namecheap did that); and then a judge can force that privacy to be revoked.
I.e. "We found that Namecheap’s proxy service, Whoisguard, registered or used 45 domain names" - it's not that 45 John Does have registered these domains and we want their identities, we know who is the official owner of these domains is - it's Whoisguard; and it's up to Whoisguard to either accept full responsibility for the [mis]use of these domains or provide some arguments why someone else should be held responsible instead.
If "internet standard process" is that they should do something else other then sue Namecheap - well, that works as far as that other thing works faster/better/cheaper than suing Namecheap directly. If it does not, then the legal process is that they can sue Namecheap if it feels more effective.
In essence what seems to be happening here is testing in a court whether the current practice of domain "privacy proxies" can be done without the proxy accepting any liability for the domains they're shielding. Such services were implemented in the notion that they don't intend to accept any liability, but as far as I know it has not yet been tested in courts whether they can get away with it.
It's worth noting that in many other similar aspects (e.g. copyright issues for user generated content, etc) the default position was that proxies can be held liable as accomplices, and that changed only when specific laws were passed saying that such proxies are immune from liability if certain conditions are met (e.g. common carrier, dmca, etc, etc). So, depending on how the courts rule, it's plausible that we might get precedent that domain privacy proxies do have to bear some liability if they happend to protect the anonymity of criminals, which would de facto mean that those proxies won't exist, that all such services would shut down.