Lots of people can do the job. Is this person a learner? And what kind of learner. Learn on the job? Learn in your free time? And what does this person like to learn?
Lots of people can do the job. Is this person a learner? And what kind of learner. Learn on the job? Learn in your free time? And what does this person like to learn?
Here's the thing though. I don't want to work with an engineer who hasn't read anything technical in the last year. Don't care how good of a problem solver they are, if they don't teach themselves things they probably aren't very passionate about the profession.
Last year I took a year-long sabbatical and went to New Zealand. I spent half of that time offline. During that, I read 4 technical books. I really enjoyed that.
Before and after that I don't really have the time to read through a book in a meaningful way. After work my brain is to tired to focus more than a few pages. I still read relevant blog posts that are usually more dense and short so I don't loose focus while reading.
There is always a subjective reason why someone can fail.
Whiteboards? Some don't perform well with those. Take-home assignments? People can lookup solutions. Everything can be used.
Asking someone: what did you learn in the last year? How? And what did you gain out of it?
These don't seem hard and unfair questions to ask.
You are saying loud and clear you assess how good an engineer is fit for a role literally judging part of personal life based on your own (100% unbiased, right?) inference process.
I find it funny that I received a lot of criticism for this, when companies out there are still giving people BS riddles and "find the leaf with the value 'x' in a binary tree in O(logn)", or whatever crap they ask, to assess how good an engineer is, however, asking for how someone learns, how updated someone is, etc., is a something you should not take into account, while I find this very important, because it shows an important aspect of the person's attitude.
I think that we should stop hiring coders, and we should start hiring people. And people have interests, such as reading, fishing, etc.