And Chelsea is not serving a sentence for committing a crime; like the article states, she is being detained indefinitely for refusing to testify.
And Chelsea is not serving a sentence for committing a crime; like the article states, she is being detained indefinitely for refusing to testify.
But I also believe that it is a clear violation of the 6th and 8th amendments to indefinitely detain someone without a trial.
These sorts of extreme and unusual actions erode the credibility of the entire judicial system in the eyes of the public.
If a judge wants someone imprisoned for a valid legal reason, they should be able to get a jury of that person's peers to agree. That's what prevents our judiciary from becoming arbitrary tool of oppression.
Juries never decided questions of authority and validity of judicial decisions. That's just not how juries work in common law.
> If a judge wants someone imprisoned for a valid legal reason, they should be able to get a jury of that person's peers to agree.
That may be your ideal picture, but again that's not how common law system works, and also not how it can work - if somebody would just refuse to comply with judicial orders, and you'd require a new jury trial each time one needs to be compelled to appear in hearing, answer a question, comply with a subpoena, etc. then you won't be able to enforce any decision and any judicial proceedings would be impossible as it would produce a fractal tree of sub-proceedings for every action, and any hostile actor would be able to bog down any proceedings by just refusing to comply with every judicial action. In actuality, there are enforcement actions in common law systems that can be performed without a jury trial. Jury trial is only necessary for conviction of a crime.
Another abhorrent example which shows where this leads: journalists can be unilaterally detained for not giving up their sources.
https://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/07/politics/reporter-jailed-...