PS - I'm young and pissed with the general recklessness of baby boomers.
PS - I'm young and pissed with the general recklessness of baby boomers.
If you haven't, read Lee Iacoca's autobiography: http://www.amazon.com/Iacocca-Autobiography-Lee/dp/055325147...
He wrote it in 1984, but everything he says applies to the 2008/2009 collapse of the auto industry. For that matter, go back a little further and read John DeLorean's On a Clear Day You Can See General Motors. It's pretty amazing how long these poorly run companies managed to trip along, and these books make it pretty clear it's not just the unions to blame.
Anyway, if you want to look at excessive compensation and benefits in the auto industry, look a little higher.
And at any rate, they only got what they negotiated, so if you want to blame anyone, blame management for poor negotiating, poor planning and just generally screwing up.
Finally, if unions ruined the auto industry, why is Ford doing well relative to GM and Chrysler? I drive a foreign car at the moment, but my next car will be a Ford because they did not take bailout money, and they make excellent, reliable cars (nowadays).
As for the assemblers preventing innovation, its much harder to pump cash into R&D when your assembly costs are twice that of your competition.
And as for ford doing well relative to GM and Crysler, you're basically saying they're doing good compared to bankruptcy. I like ford (especially their current lineup), but they've fallen a long way from their massive dominance of a few decades back.
To be clear, I agree with you (this reply seems a little ranty), the entire auto industry is a mess; a large part of these inefficiencies I feel comes out of dealing with unions - and I see the same things happening with teachers.
But to put your last statement another way, a large part of these inefficiencies comes out of having to create unions in the first place, to counter the abusive employment practices of management.
I think it's a two-way street. Auto unions are corrupt now, but they were obviously created as a reaction to some pretty bad behavior from management.
The worst, most unnecessary, most counter-productive unions, in my limited experience, are at universities :)
Work rules.
Anyway, if you want to look at excessive compensation and benefits in the auto industry, look a little higher.
$3 million + worthless stock options ($15M at the time of issue) is not that high.
http://www.mlive.com/business/index.ssf/2009/03/gm_ceos_2008...
Lets compare that to what some Google employees earn:
http://www.oochoo.com/2010/11/google-offers-3-5-million-doll...
1. Work rules created the quality problems? The quality was engineered right out of the cars through cost-cutting and bad priorities.
2. 2008? American car companies got into trouble decades before 2008.
3. Google is profitable, whereas GM and Chrysler failed, took bailouts, never punished their own management, same as the bankers.
4. Paying $3 million for failure is acceptable? Okay, so why is paying $50k to a line worker "too much" then?
Regarding 3), Wagoner's comp was cut from $14.9M to $3M as a result of his failure. $3M is very little for an executive at his level. Even $14.9M is not that high for a CEO of a company as big as GM. Lady Gaga earned $62M in the same time period.
Regarding 4), GM is saddled with legacy costs of $1600/car. The CEO's pay of $3 million works out to be $8.35/vehicle.
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/05_19/b3932001_...
http://www.gm.com/investors/sales-production/press-release.j...
Suppose the next best alternative available for CEO would only demand $2 million. If Wagoner could increase profits by $2.78/vehicle more than the next best option for CEO, his pay is well worth it. Do you seriously think you can get a competent CEO, capable of running GM, for less than $1 million?
We're talking about different decades. You're talking about present day, I'm talking about how we got here, i.e., the decline which began in the 1980's.
In terms of what a CEO is "worth," CEO's can certainly have negative value, regardless of the compensation.
Regarding who should take a pay cut, I would say everyone involved. But what I'm objecting to is this notion that "unions are to blame" for the auto industry's problems.
Let's assume the unions are acting like leeches, sucking out more value than they are putting in. Isn't it arguably the case that management is acting -exactly- the same way?
I would further argue that there is a -lot- more than $1600/car that separates GM from Toyota. If the unions are to blame for everything wrong, do they get the credit at companies which are doing well (e.g., Ford)?
Do you seriously believe GM would have a higher value if the CEO position went unfilled?
Let's assume the unions are acting like leeches, sucking out more value than they are putting in. Isn't it arguably the case that management is acting -exactly- the same way?
Perhaps, but management doesn't have much power. If management demands more money than the company is willing to pay, they can be fired and replaced. That's a lot harder with unionized workers.
The gap between GM and Toyota may be more than $1600/car, but all that means is that unions are not the only cause of GM's decline. I wouldn't disagree with that.
As for Ford, what exactly did the unions do to help? The mechanism by which they harm is quite clear - they raise cost of labor. What value do they add that makes it worthwhile?
No, of course they have to have a CEO. And maybe he adds value, maybe not. He gets what he negotiated, same as the workers.
Management doesn't have much power? You're saying that an individual manager doesn't have much power and can be replaced. Sure, that's true.
As for Ford, let me clarify. No, I'm not saying the unions deserve any credit -- after all, it's the same unions as at GM!
But if you're going to give them the blame when things are bad, don't you have to also then give them the credit when things are good? The truth is they are just assembly line workers for the most part, and the quality was engineered out of the cars starting in the 1980's.
And regarding the "harm" that workers do by raising the cost of labor, why aren't management's salaries also "harming" the business by raising the cost? Why the double standard?
The corporation negotiates with management from a position of equality. Both parties are permitted to make or reject offers as they see fit. If GM offers too little, Wagoner is free to take a higher paying job elsewhere. If GM can find someone cheaper, they are free to reject Wagoner. GM is also not permitted to collude with other employers to reduce prices.
The corporation does not negotiate with a union from a position of equality. They are not permitted to reject union offers and procure labor at lower rates from the competition. They are also not permitted to fire and replace union workers who fail to do their jobs. Labor sellers are legally permitted to collude with each other to raise their prices, and they are given a government granted monopoly on the practice. Competition is illegal.
You make the case that management is an innocent by-stander getting repeatedly mugged by unions. The truth is that the treachery went both ways, historically. Otherwise, why do unions exist?
[Auto makers] are also not permitted to fire and replace union workers who fail to do their jobs.
I wonder how many managers at GM have ever been fired for "failing to do their jobs," in light of the bailout. The lack of accountability is on both sides, not just one side.
The fundamental problem is that as a whole there is neither some better performing nor cheaper workforce that is being blocked access to teaching today.