No -- I am arguing that alignment, consistency, appropriate typography, non-mediocre use of color are only NOTICED and cared about by 1%.
Overall usability is what the other 99% care about. And should be of primary importance.
Saying that overall usability == "alignment, consistency, appropriate typography, non-mediocre use of color" is just not true.
Usability is one type of design. Those are another. They are not synonymous.