The problem is that this blocking induces some failures which are hard to diagnose. For instance, on the official site of my city I can't use some pages because they loop on requiring my authentication, since they use iframes with shared cookies. On other sites, submitting a form will fail with no error messages. I also remember a Python MOOC that failed with a blank page because of this blocking. Fortunately, all of these errors are uncommon.
Now some huge double-digit share of traffic is going to encounter these issues, and force sites that depend on 3rd party cookies to re-architect themselves to support "normal" people on their iPhones.
My wife finds that various sites just don't work so I have to disable it whilst she checks out.
If these 3rd party cookies and domains are highlighted and force people's practices to change a bit, I will be happy.
I just don't understand people that run a site that relies on so many third-party sources to actually function. Since the site owner is not in control of the third-party reliability or uptime, it is essentially handing control/resiliance of the original site to the third-party (and putting the fate of their shop in it too). Absolutely baffling.
This is the front loaded approach which can cause breakage. I prefer the back loaded approach of using an extension like Cookie Auto Delete or similar that deletes cookies once you're away from a domain for a set amount of time (I think mine is set to 2 minutes).
I just tried the new Safari Preview and this indeed stopped our framed web app from working. I managed to get it somewhat working again by asking permission via the new Storage Access API. Yet another popup users need to click through, ugh. I also managed to get one Safari Preview in a state where it would consistently deny access, without prompting the user again. This is going to make for painful support tickets.
I guess a more permanent solution would to ask my customers to put a piece of JavaScript on their page so we can set first party cookies but that seems a support nightmare as well. Any other suggestions to work around this would be most welcome.