That's just for robotic/satellite missions. It's ten times worse when a manned mission ends fatally.
I'm sorry, but this argument is also mathematically illiterate. Probability only works this way if the events are uncorrelated, but it should be pretty clear they're not.
If the first rocket has a 20% chance to fail it is likely that the second one will also fail due to similar negligence.
Rockets aren't mass manufactured and their fabrication is barely automated. Nobody except SpaceX keeps their tooling online long enough to have correlating failures except for actual design issues which are fixed in later launches. The correlated failure comes from the actual mission hardware but launch schedules are so spread out that a second mission has plenty of time to fix issues discovered in the first attempt.
If rockets, which are made one at a time and launch maybe a few times a year, had correlating failures like you said, no insurance company would cover launches.
I don't disagree but I also don't think it's always as straightforward as probability theory would make us believe. One can imagine situations where a certain amount of QA leads to a certain semi-predictable amount of failures that allows for calculated risks to be taken, but one can also imagine situations where paying 2X leads to better solutions and processes and not paying 2X leads to failure on both the first and second launches.
NASA has its Artemis program which is doing exactly this, returning to the Moon with a goal of a longer-term lunar base.
And they just held a period of application (it closed a few days ago) for the next generation of Artemis astronauts.
Artemis : https://www.nasa.gov/specials/artemis/
So another new moon plan. Another Shuttle derived launcher.
Not surprising that nobody is getting very exited with Artemis.
The SLS and Orion can only be described as dead-weights on NASA since they are so incredibly expensive. SLS has been in development for over 10 years at more then 2 billion per year and it will not launch until 2022 hopefully.
They've been designing Orion for a couple decades now, and the SLS is a shuttle-derived expendable launcher where what we see as key innovations are mounting 25% more SSMEs (still expendable) on the bottom of the fuel tank, extending the SRBs by a couple segments and putting the payload on top of the main tank.
Ares was interesting and we learned, with Ares I, that we shouldn't put humans on top of an SRB. There would probably be cheaper ways to find that out, but at least they tried something different.
1. The risk is different when there are human lives on the line.
2. NASA is publicly funded and if they want to keep receiving funding, they can’t be blowing up the public’s money.
Obviously, there's not much tolerance when human lives on the line. But you don't have to test with humans.
From my armchair perspective I think the risk adversity criticism is justified. NASA should take much more risk even in human spaceflight... in the early stages of platform development. First see if you can build the damn thing and build it repeatedly. Later, after that period, reduce risk and prove out and refine things to the human spaceflight standard. If you jump immediately to, "my God people are suppose to fly on that thing!" well, you're probably going to pay the Russians a lot of money for a fairly long time.
I do agree with you that the political management becomes a real issue. Politicians and bureaucrats are naturally disposed to a certain cravenness about such issues once they get to significant positions of power (senior execs of many companies do, too). But I think a charismatic leader that's out in front of the messaging could pull it off.
It is also absolutely embarrassing that we still haven't fully surveyed the moon for resources, dont know where all the ice is, etc. Lunar rovers should be numbering in the hundreds, maybe thousands.
They literally couldn't do it, and the admired that they basically can't develop it internally without it costing 10s of billions.
So that's why the used the Commercial Crew program and that worked out for them.
The SLS is a good example, 10+ years of building at a cost far above 20+ billion until the first launch.
2. Dirty little secret: even when NASA uses “startups” like SpaceX to launch and things go awry, the taxpayers are still on the hook for the majority of the loss because the Agency is self-insured