Also saving capital but a 10yr bet on self driving cars.
Also saving capital but a 10yr bet on self driving cars.
Google Photos I think is reasonably successful, but mostly as "where your Android's photos end up". I am not sure how many people have a strong relationship with Google Photos. And I still hear about people upset about Google killing Picasa in favor of it. It is worth nothing that Picasa, the foundation of Photos, was not something Google developed, but something Google acquired from outside.
Former Google Talk supported XMMP, including federation, which meant you could connect with multiple clients and talk with people talk with people that don't have Google accounts.
With Hangouts politics took over. They eventually told people the line about XMMP not evolving fast enough for their needs. But I remember their leadership complaining about their competition not playing nice.
So when Hangouts happened I saw absolutely no reason to use it. There were plenty of alternatives on the market already, at work we were all using Skype. And at that time I was working with former Googlers that preferred Google's shit.
You might give me the line about the general population not caring, bla, bla, but Google is in the habit of betraying their power users and early adopters. They did it with Google Reader. They did it with Inbox.
And I was actually glad to see Hangouts fail. It might have been a good implementation of yet another chat app, but few people cared.
My beta users are using it for free in exchange for their feedback. I'm hoping to release the final beta within a week. After beta there will be free and paid tiers.
Read more: https://photostructure.com/about/introducing-photostructure/
—————————-
Flights is from 2011, nine years ago. And they bought the logic at the core of it from ITA.
Google drive is a genuine success, but from 2012, eight years ago.
Even hangouts, which is a failure, is from 2013.
What became Tensorflow appears to have begun seeing internal use in 2009-11.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Flights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Drive
Even by official public release it’s almost five years old.
The OP was arguing that google had had several recent successes, but their list tends to be 5+ years old. The point is that such a list is not especially convincing.
I should note that my point in mentioning the early origins of tensorflow was that google had a reputation for being more innovative in those years. So it is also meaningful that Tensorflow’s origins are from that period.
Google’s modern reputation is introducing a new chat app each year and deprecating the old one.
I think you’re adding stuff into my comment that’s not there. My point was that nothing on the list was from newer than 2015. Except maybe google photos, but that came out of Picasa/Google+
Photos has some kind of weird resolution limitation that turned me off the product immediately. (Plus I'm not crazy about Google having all my personal photos to mine.)
Tensorflow seems pretty good; I'd prefer not to be controlling high-speed computational resources with a super-slow interpreted language that cannot even multitask, but everything runs on Python nowadays.
I don't use the rest enough to comment.
Also I really like my Google home, Pixel phone, and Nest cameras -- privacy concerns aside :grimace:
I think the real problem is when google releases a free[1] product they have a track record of discontinuing them seemingly (from user's point of view) at random so that people are beginning to feel that it's not safe to build on any new products from them.
[1] "Free" in this case meaning actually free, e.g. doesn't actively support their core spying + advertising business
> so if a product does not do well in a set time frame, it is shut down
Gmail was a success from the beginning. Android is doing pretty well. Chrome did a mix of growth because it was just better at the time, and ads which made it popular. They all did very well.
Interestingly, I don't think that was obvious from inside the company.
Maybe some day this will be declassified by one of the early PMs or engineers, it's a great story.
Later on, the campaign of "complaints" about how empty it was got them to change bits of it, pushing "follow those people" on you that was filled with brain-numbing celebs and the like, and the magic was gone.
Whoever orchestrated that campaign should get a raise (and shouldn't meet me, as G+ was last web-based social media that I could earnestly use)
Wave got partially opensourced, after a while. I'm sure someone would buy Google trips.
Sure, Google itself wouldn't benefit much from those, but if they're killing the service anyway, it would improve the image.
For things on the Google stack selling isn't really easy.
Things they acquired , like picassa, could probably be sold again, but there they wanted to migrate to Google Photos.
> For things on the Google stack selling isn't really easy.
If Google would build their new products using only publicly available GCP features, that would be a really smart move.
It would signal that they're confident enough about GCP to build their own products on it, and they can spin off products that are small successes but not large enough to move the needle at Google scale. Or if they're not profitable, open source them and allow people to run their own instance of it on GCP if they want.