The market for electricity isn't very "efficient" in that way, a utility or market doesn't buy and sell from an individual power plant so the price/profitability of a single plant doesn't reflect the supply/demand from that plant.
The market for electricity isn't very "efficient" in that way, a utility or market doesn't buy and sell from an individual power plant so the price/profitability of a single plant doesn't reflect the supply/demand from that plant.
So obviously profitability isn’t the only thing keeping these plants open or not.
Additionally:
but this risks locking in high-cost coal power
Coal is only high-cost when compared against certain metrics that favour non-coal electricity sources.
On the whole electricity is extremely cheap, even from fossil sources, and where the end user may pay enough to care about total usage, the major components of the retail price are not source related, but rather delivery / tax / administrative / bureaucratic.
However, why would I do that when everyone else isn’t.
And how would I do that when there’s no economic framework for me, as an individual retail customer, to do so?
Sure, I can buy 100% renewables, but here in Australia the retailers want to charge me more for that choice. Here in Tasmania the local retailer, Aurora Energy, wants an additional 6.023 cents / kWh for 100% renewable, that’s that’s on top of their peak rate of 32.587 cents / kWh. An additional 18.5%!
Why would I do that if I’m already living near my economic ability?
Edit to add:
And, even if I did choose to pay that premium, it’ll have approximately no effect whatsoever on global climate outcomes. Me paying an additional 18.5% on my bill to feel good won’t suck the carbon out of the air!
This is why we neee regulation in this scenario more than we need individual choice.