Well, as far as I know, the antibodies do disappear at some point, but now your immune system knows the virus and can quickly produce new antibodies again, if it finds the virus again. But I think over time the immune system also forgets.
But to the patients that got sick again. "Bad test" would be the best outcome yes, but I know, that with herpes virus for example, you can never really get rid of them. Your immune system defeats them, but some virus cells remain in stasis somewhere sleeping - and resurface, if your stress level is high enough. So it would not surprise me, if this coronavirus might have similar traits.